Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Jef Gorbach" data-source="post: 7564467" data-attributes="member: 6953678">&quot;The subject at hand is &quot;creating&quot; an entry in a spell book. Per the rules you can scribe a *SPELL* from a scroll. The *SPELL* in our example is Fireball. It may have some bells and whistles, good sound system and chrome spinner wheel covers, but it's still Fireball. The Metamagic gets left behind because, while it may be part of the scroll, it isn't part of the spell.&quot;Disagree, the author scribed a Cold Fireball which how/why anyone using the scroll casts it including the metamagic adjustments. RAW says you are copying the spell on the scroll, thus the copied version is the Cold Fireball; unless the copier both has the metamagic feats used AND intentionally rewrites it without the metamagic modifications. IRL, its like finding a Chocolate Chip Pnut butter cookie recipe and deciding to copy it into your cookbook. You cant rewrite it to make sugar cookies unless you recognize what modifications were originally made.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Jef Gorbach, post: 7564467, member: 6953678"] "The subject at hand is "creating" an entry in a spell book. Per the rules you can scribe a *SPELL* from a scroll. The *SPELL* in our example is Fireball. It may have some bells and whistles, good sound system and chrome spinner wheel covers, but it's still Fireball. The Metamagic gets left behind because, while it may be part of the scroll, it isn't part of the spell." Disagree, the author scribed a Cold Fireball which how/why anyone using the scroll casts it including the metamagic adjustments. RAW says you are copying the spell on the scroll, thus the copied version is the Cold Fireball; unless the copier both has the metamagic feats used AND intentionally rewrites it without the metamagic modifications. IRL, its like finding a Chocolate Chip Pnut butter cookie recipe and deciding to copy it into your cookbook. You cant rewrite it to make sugar cookies unless you recognize what modifications were originally made. [/QUOTE]

Verification