Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Striderman" data-source="post: 52666" data-attributes="member: 2430">I know this kind of goes the opposite direction of my earlier post, but I am only presenting arguments, anyway, and this is a fun debate.Anyway, depending on how one decides the True Strike spell works in his/her game, it might be reasoned that rather than the insight being where your opponent is, the insight is only where your weapon is going to go.&nbsp; Yes, this is a very flimsy argument, and yes, it could still go both ways, but it is still an interesting point (at least to me).&nbsp; Personally, I think that the best option is not to try to reason how the spell might actually function (even though I just did that a moment ago), but rather to decide how well it fits into the balance of things.&nbsp; Is it a game breaker to allow the True Strike to work against a Mind Blanked opponent?&nbsp; I don't think so.&nbsp; That is why I would lean towards allowing it.&nbsp; OTOH, does it make sense or cause problems for the Mind Blank to foil the True Strike?&nbsp; The idea sounds logical to me.&nbsp; That is why I might lean in that direction.&nbsp; So basically, my suggestion is that you remember that the DM is GOD and let him/her do what he/she wants with it.&nbsp; :Þ</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Striderman, post: 52666, member: 2430"] I know this kind of goes the opposite direction of my earlier post, but I am only presenting arguments, anyway, and this is a fun debate. Anyway, depending on how one decides the True Strike spell works in his/her game, it might be reasoned that rather than the insight being where your opponent is, the insight is only where your weapon is going to go. Yes, this is a very flimsy argument, and yes, it could still go both ways, but it is still an interesting point (at least to me). Personally, I think that the best option is not to try to reason how the spell might actually function (even though I just did that a moment ago), but rather to decide how well it fits into the balance of things. Is it a game breaker to allow the True Strike to work against a Mind Blanked opponent? I don't think so. That is why I would lean towards allowing it. OTOH, does it make sense or cause problems for the Mind Blank to foil the True Strike? The idea sounds logical to me. That is why I might lean in that direction. So basically, my suggestion is that you remember that the DM is GOD and let him/her do what he/she wants with it. :Þ [/QUOTE]

Verification