Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Scribble" data-source="post: 4218550" data-attributes="member: 23977">The issue is that I would guess that your bloodrager character would, even under your system, be better off finding another opponent as you'll most likely kill it before it gets bloodied anyway.Again the issue being... ok so you missed and should have done damamge anyway... Assume you only did half of it's HP in damage. If the chances are so low that you will miss on your next attack that the half damamge you did wouldn't add anything to the situation (except to make the foe extra dead?) why make the DM do the extra tracking? I think that minions will prove to be a case of, it looks wonky on paper, but once we actually start playing will prove to be just an easier form of doing it by tracking HP and accounting for average damage and such...Why are the players deciding this? If the DM decides he wants to treat the minion as a bloodrager say... just change the stats you're using and pretend like you just never had him use his powers for some reason?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Scribble, post: 4218550, member: 23977"] The issue is that I would guess that your bloodrager character would, even under your system, be better off finding another opponent as you'll most likely kill it before it gets bloodied anyway. Again the issue being... ok so you missed and should have done damamge anyway... Assume you only did half of it's HP in damage. If the chances are so low that you will miss on your next attack that the half damamge you did wouldn't add anything to the situation (except to make the foe extra dead?) why make the DM do the extra tracking? I think that minions will prove to be a case of, it looks wonky on paper, but once we actually start playing will prove to be just an easier form of doing it by tracking HP and accounting for average damage and such... Why are the players deciding this? If the DM decides he wants to treat the minion as a bloodrager say... just change the stats you're using and pretend like you just never had him use his powers for some reason? [/QUOTE]

Verification