Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Dryfus" data-source="post: 2687792" data-attributes="member: 33775">And it isn't an assumption that they do??they CAN be touched, doesn't nessicarrily mean that they have resistance, and if they do how much.In a magical society/world??  I would say that they would cover the gammit of what a fighter is likley to run into in the big bad world, not just the "solid" thingsIn most of the games I've played in/DM'd, if a charachters POV was ignored, the players were less likley to suspend their disbeliefJust because we interperit(sp?) RAW differently, doesn't mean that either one of us is wrong.  It just means we have different beliefs in how things should work in a society/world of our imagination.  And it does accomplish something, IMO.    Besides, I believe that the RAW supports my position.  (isn't that what were disscussing here??)  Let me ask you some questions then.  1)  Two characters start fighting. One a wizaed, one a fighter.  The PC with the fighter  states "I'll attack the Wizard with my sword(axe/mace/whatever).  His target is a creature??2) same as 1, but the wizard has cast mirror image.  does the same condition apply, if not, why??after I have some answers here, I'll ask more, but without some more info I cant right now.</blockquote>