Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Shade" data-source="post: 3115789" data-attributes="member: 287">I finally had a chance to take an in-depth look at a friends' copy, and I'm still not sorry I haven't bought it.   Beyond the obvious disappoint of the inclusion of classed MM monsters, the non-psionic githyanki, the large amount of space wasted on dragonspawn, and the lack of any updated monsters, here are but a few of the disappointing aspects of the monsters included.The new fiends bug me the most.   First, the new yugoloths don't feel much like yugoloths.   From the abandonment of their always used naming conventions (-"loth" or -"daemon" for you old-schoolers) to the lack of common yugoloth powers (neither has the summon ability, which even the lowly skeroloth possesses, for example), these guys just don't feel like yugoloths.   Add to the fact that the corruptor of fate only advances by class level, and it might as well be a generic extraplanar humanoid.   Outsiders can advance by class levels; however, they nearly always advance by Hit Dice.   Sure, that rule isn't written in stone anywhere, but it definitely detracts from the creature feeling like a yugoloth.    The flavor text doesn't present much more of a case for them to be yugoloths.  About the only thing that they have in common with other yugoloths is their home plane and mercenary nature.  The voor is much better; granting it a more appropriate name (I believe Shemeska recommended "vooroloth", which works) and a summon ability, and you've got yourself a yugoloth.On to the demons...While I have no problems with non-tanar'ri demons (I love those obyriths and loumaras),  3 of the 4 listed under the demon entry are not members of any of these three groups.   This makes them difficult to fit in.Starting with the deathdrinker...how does this thing continue to thrive in the Abyss?  With its superiority complex and lack of powerful special abilities, it should be extinct by now with the vast numbers of tanar'ri that wouldn't suffer its attitude.   It brings very little benefit to the table, and its ecology section really only points out why it doesn't care for the tanar'ri's concerns...not why they'd put up with it for one minute.   At least they seem to have some sort of role "in Faerun".   And here we have yet another fiend that only advances "by class"...ugh.  But it's biggest problem is its use of Quicken Spell-Like Ability (greater teleport), which figures prominently into its strategies.   As a 7th-level spell, this is impossible.   Quicken SLA only allows up to 6th-level spells at CL 20th.Next up is the kastighur.   Now this is a demon done right...a good mix of abilities, an appropriate role in the ecology of the Abyss...no qualms here.And now things take a turn for the worse again.   The nashrou's one defining ability is a weakness...vulnerability to criticals.   This seems like an excuse to let them dish out far more damage than usual for a CR 2 creature with reach and nearly four times as many hit points as any other demons of its CR.   So your party either gets a lucky hit or dies.  Thanks to the new improved critical/keen/etc. not stacking rules, the odds are that the nashrou wins.   And at CR 2 the spellcasters don't have flight yet, so everyone's on the ground, and doubtfully outrunning its 50 ft. base speed.Whisper demons are neat creatures with interesting abilities...but nothing in their entry seems to really indicate why they are demons.  Perhaps there was a demon quota to be filled?Now we come to the are-they-or-aren't they wrackspawn.   First, they aren't listed in the demon category.  If they are demons, that's annoying (much like the chain golem in the MM2 listed away from the rest of the golems).   The lore states that a wrackspawn is "a minor demon".  and a "demonic footsoldier", so I suppose that makes them demons.   At CR 3, they appear far less deadly than the CR 2 nashrou.  The well-written flavor text redeems them, though.Many of the creatures in the MMIV have sections that describe at what level of summon monster they can be summoned.   While I applaud the return to this form, what happened to the MMIII mandate that any additions to the summon monster list must have another creature removed?   For example, permanently removing the babau from the list to add the arrow demon?   Like I said, I prefer the MMIV method, but a little sidebar might have been nice to explain that we're going back to the old ways.Finally, the Lore DCs really bug me.  As Merric pointed out, they switched to a function of CR rather than HD, which once again creates rules inconsistency and confusion.   I also dislike the fact that the lowest check result reveals all type and subtype traits.   While I'm fine with players learning that a creature is an outsider and has darkvision 60 ft. and doesn't need to eat or sleep, I don't like the fact that the lowest result reveals that a tanar'ri has immunity to electricity and poison, resistance to acid 10, cold 10, and fire 10, the ability to summon others of their kind, and telepathy.  That's way too much info for the lowest result, especially when the immunities of simpler creatures can't be learned until the 2nd-highest or highest result.There are some interesting creatures in this book, but overall I'd still call it a colossal disappointment.</blockquote>

Verification