Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Hussar" data-source="post: 6138364" data-attributes="member: 22779">Really?It was suggested that Yuguloths could worship gods.&nbsp; In this thread it was suggested.&nbsp; That idea was shot down, without any discussion, not because the idea was bad, but because it contradicted Planescape canon.It was suggested that demons and devils could work together.&nbsp; Automatically shot down because demons and devils hate each other.&nbsp; Which is only true if you accept Planescape lore.&nbsp; Outside of Planescape and the Blood War (which I honestly do lump together), there is nothing to even suggest that demons and devils can't work together.It was suggested that Slaad could be aberrations, and not outsiders.&nbsp; Again, idea shot down, not because it was a bad idea (it very well might be) but because it contradicted Planescape canon.4e changes to cosmology are constantly derided simply because they contradict Planescape canon.&nbsp; On and on.&nbsp; Any change to any Planescape lore is met with instant and automatic rejection.&nbsp; Try it sometime.&nbsp; Suggest changes to planar lore and see how far you get.As far as stuff outside of core like the Manual of the Planes?&nbsp; Go ahead.&nbsp; Do whatever you want.&nbsp; That's a supplement and I can take it or leave it.&nbsp; But, please, keep it out of core.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Hussar, post: 6138364, member: 22779"] Really? It was suggested that Yuguloths could worship gods. In this thread it was suggested. That idea was shot down, without any discussion, not because the idea was bad, but because it contradicted Planescape canon. It was suggested that demons and devils could work together. Automatically shot down because demons and devils hate each other. Which is only true if you accept Planescape lore. Outside of Planescape and the Blood War (which I honestly do lump together), there is nothing to even suggest that demons and devils can't work together. It was suggested that Slaad could be aberrations, and not outsiders. Again, idea shot down, not because it was a bad idea (it very well might be) but because it contradicted Planescape canon. 4e changes to cosmology are constantly derided simply because they contradict Planescape canon. On and on. Any change to any Planescape lore is met with instant and automatic rejection. Try it sometime. Suggest changes to planar lore and see how far you get. As far as stuff outside of core like the Manual of the Planes? Go ahead. Do whatever you want. That's a supplement and I can take it or leave it. But, please, keep it out of core. [/QUOTE]

Verification