Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="sfedi" data-source="post: 5000234" data-attributes="member: 15746">You're right. I was using my houserule of +1 per level.Oh, and I left the "100 surges" from a previous simulation.Here's the above but all of the above corrected:[sblock]Level 1 Dwarf Greatweapon Fighter VS. Level 1 Soldier[sblock=Combatants][code]PCs  Level 1 Dwarf Greatweapon Fighter    Stats: HP 27; AC 17; Healing Surges 10    ReapingStrike (standard; at-will) 7 vs AC; 2d5+8; Miss: 4 damage    Attack (standard; encounter) 7 vs AC; 4d5+10    Attack (standard; daily; reliable) 7 vs AC; 6d5+12    SecondWind (minor; encounter)Monsters  Level 1 Soldier    Stats: HP 29; AC 17; Healing Surges 1    BasicAttack (standard; at-will) 8 vs AC; 1d10+2    Attack (standard; encounter) 8 vs AC; 2d10+2[/code][/sblock][sblock=Statistics][code]Fights simulated: 1000Avg rounds (per combat): 3.9  2 (12.0%): =======================  3 (45.8%): ===================================================================  4 (69.3%): ==============================================  5 (86.5%): ==================================  6 (95.1%): =================  7 (98.9%): =======  8 (99.8%): =  9 (99.9%):  10(100.0%):  11(100.0%):  12(100.0%): Avg combats survived in a day (fights survived): 4.2  0  (8.5%): ====================================  1 (18.4%): ==========================================  2 (26.4%): ==================================  3 (37.2%): ==============================================  4 (52.4%): ================================================================  5 (68.1%): ===================================================================  6 (83.3%): ================================================================  7 (92.7%): ========================================  8 (97.3%): ===================  9 (99.0%): ======= 10 (99.5%): == 11 (99.8%): = 12(100.0%): Avg percentage of dailies used per day: 79.5[/code][/sblock]Level 1 Dwarf Greatweapon Fighter VS. Level 2 Soldier[sblock=Combatants][code]PCs  Level 1 Dwarf Greatweapon Fighter    Stats: HP 27; AC 17; Healing Surges 10    ReapingStrike (standard; at-will) 7 vs AC; 2d5+8; Miss: 4 damage    Attack (standard; encounter) 7 vs AC; 4d5+10    Attack (standard; daily; reliable) 7 vs AC; 6d5+12    SecondWind (minor; encounter)Monsters  Level 2 Soldier    Stats: HP 37; AC 18; Healing Surges 1    BasicAttack (standard; at-will) 9 vs AC; 1d10+2    Attack (standard; encounter) 9 vs AC; 2d10+2[/code][/sblock][sblock=Statistics][code]Fights simulated: 1000Avg rounds (per combat): 4.7  2  (4.1%): =========  3 (22.0%): =========================================  4 (50.7%): ===================================================================  5 (72.6%): ===================================================  6 (88.0%): ===================================  7 (95.7%): =================  8 (99.0%): =======  9 (99.7%): = 10 (99.9%):  11(100.0%):  12(100.0%): Avg combats survived in a day (fights survived): 2.3  0 (18.4%): ==============================================================  1 (38.2%): ===================================================================  2 (54.5%): =======================================================  3 (71.1%): ========================================================  4 (88.2%): =========================================================  5 (96.2%): ===========================  6 (99.1%): =========  7 (99.9%): ==  8(100.0%): Avg percentage of dailies used per day: 75.2[/code][/sblock]Level 1 Dwarf Greatweapon Fighter VS. Level 3 Soldier[sblock=Combatants][code]PCs  Level 1 Dwarf Greatweapon Fighter    Stats: HP 27; AC 17; Healing Surges 10    ReapingStrike (standard; at-will) 7 vs AC; 2d5+8; Miss: 4 damage    Attack (standard; encounter) 7 vs AC; 4d5+10    Attack (standard; daily; reliable) 7 vs AC; 6d5+12    SecondWind (minor; encounter)Monsters  Level 3 Soldier    Stats: HP 45; AC 19; Healing Surges 1    BasicAttack (standard; at-will) 10 vs AC; 1d10+3    Attack (standard; encounter) 10 vs AC; 2d10+3[/code][/sblock][sblock=Statistics][code]Fights simulated: 1000Avg rounds (per combat): 5.2  2  (1.7%): ====  3  (9.1%): =================  4 (36.6%): ===================================================================  5 (63.8%): ==================================================================  6 (83.3%): ===============================================  7 (92.8%): =======================  8 (98.1%): ============  9 (99.6%): === 10 (99.8%):  11(100.0%): Avg combats survived in a day (fights survived): 1.0  0 (39.7%): ===================================================================  1 (74.8%): ===========================================================  2 (88.8%): =======================  3 (97.1%): ==============  4 (99.5%): ====  5(100.0%): Avg percentage of dailies used per day: 65.7[/code][/sblock]Level 1 Dwarf Greatweapon Fighter VS. Level 4 Soldier[sblock=Combatants][code]PCs  Level 1 Dwarf Greatweapon Fighter    Stats: HP 27; AC 17; Healing Surges 10    ReapingStrike (standard; at-will) 7 vs AC; 2d5+8; Miss: 4 damage    Attack (standard; encounter) 7 vs AC; 4d5+10    Attack (standard; daily; reliable) 7 vs AC; 6d5+12    SecondWind (minor; encounter)Monsters  Level 4 Soldier    Stats: HP 53; AC 20; Healing Surges 1    BasicAttack (standard; at-will) 11 vs AC; 1d10+3    Attack (standard; encounter) 11 vs AC; 2d10+3[/code][/sblock][sblock=Statistics][code]Fights simulated: 1000Avg rounds (per combat): 5.5  2  (1.3%): ===  3  (6.5%): ============  4 (27.7%): ==================================================  5 (55.5%): ===================================================================  6 (75.4%): ===============================================  7 (90.0%): ===================================  8 (96.6%): ===============  9 (99.1%): ====== 10 (99.7%): = 11(100.0%): Avg combats survived in a day (fights survived): 0.5  0 (61.3%): ===================================================================  1 (90.4%): ===============================  2 (97.2%): =======  3 (99.6%): ==  4(100.0%): Avg percentage of dailies used per day: 58.7[/code][/sblock]Level 1 Dwarf Greatweapon Fighter VS. Level 5 Soldier[sblock=Combatants][code]PCs  Level 1 Dwarf Greatweapon Fighter    Stats: HP 27; AC 17; Healing Surges 10    ReapingStrike (standard; at-will) 7 vs AC; 2d5+8; Miss: 4 damage    Attack (standard; encounter) 7 vs AC; 4d5+10    Attack (standard; daily; reliable) 7 vs AC; 6d5+12    SecondWind (minor; encounter)Monsters  Level 5 Soldier    Stats: HP 61; AC 21; Healing Surges 1    BasicAttack (standard; at-will) 12 vs AC; 1d10+4    Attack (standard; encounter) 12 vs AC; 2d10+4[/code][/sblock][sblock=Statistics][code]Fights simulated: 1000Avg rounds (per combat): 5.0  2  (0.3%):   3  (7.3%): ==============  4 (40.3%): ===================================================================  5 (68.8%): =========================================================  6 (88.0%): ======================================  7 (95.2%): ==============  8 (98.3%): ======  9 (99.5%): == 10(100.0%): =Avg combats survived in a day (fights survived): 0.2  0 (85.0%): ===================================================================  1 (98.8%): ==========  2 (99.9%):   3(100.0%): Avg percentage of dailies used per day: 47.6[/code][/sblock][/sblock]I'm going to repeat the above, with your adjustments as much as possible.Note that Reaping Strike deals less damage.I've implemented Comeback Strike but didn't modify the AI because it seems the current AI covers this.The AI chooses the more damaging power that is Encounter or more frequent.When it becomes Bloodied, then it chooses de more damaging power that is Daily or more frequent.So it seems this should work fine.You can check the code posted in previous posts.The only problem with this AI is that Comeback Strike has the same average damage as the encounter power, so it may happen that the Dwarf becomes bloodied, he hasn't used his encounter power yet (because he missed all attacks), and then ComebackStrike and Steel Serpent Strike are equal choices.Here's the same simulation as before (in this same post) but with the more defensive build:[sblock]Level 1 Dwarf Defensive Fighter VS. Level 1 Soldier[sblock=Combatants][code]PCs  Level 1 Dwarf Defensive Fighter    Stats: HP 32; AC 19; Healing Surges 10    ReapingStrike (standard; at-will) 7 vs AC; 1d10+4; Miss: 2 damage    Attack (standard; encounter) 7 vs AC; 2d10+4    ComebackStrike (standard; daily; reliable) 7 vs AC; 2d10+4    SecondWind (minor; encounter)Monsters  Level 1 Soldier    Stats: HP 29; AC 17; Healing Surges 1    BasicAttack (standard; at-will) 8 vs AC; 1d10+2    Attack (standard; encounter) 8 vs AC; 2d10+2[/code][/sblock][sblock=Statistics][code]Fights simulated: 1000Avg rounds (per combat): 5.4  2  (4.0%): ============  3 (15.4%): ===================================  4 (33.5%): ========================================================  5 (54.9%): ===================================================================  6 (73.5%): ==========================================================  7 (85.7%): ======================================  8 (93.9%): =========================  9 (97.4%): =========== 10 (99.1%): ===== 11 (99.8%): == 12 (99.9%):  13(100.0%):  14(100.0%): Avg combats survived in a day (fights survived): 4.4  0  (5.6%): ===================  1 (13.1%): ==========================  2 (21.9%): ===============================  3 (32.9%): =======================================  4 (48.4%): =======================================================  5 (67.2%): ===================================================================  6 (82.2%): =====================================================  7 (91.7%): =================================  8 (97.2%): ===================  9 (99.3%): ======= 10 (99.6%): = 11(100.0%): =Avg percentage of dailies used per day: 89.2[/code][/sblock]Level 1 Dwarf Defensive Fighter VS. Level 2 Soldier[sblock=Combatants][code]PCs  Level 1 Dwarf Defensive Fighter    Stats: HP 32; AC 19; Healing Surges 10    ReapingStrike (standard; at-will) 7 vs AC; 1d10+4; Miss: 2 damage    Attack (standard; encounter) 7 vs AC; 2d10+4    ComebackStrike (standard; daily; reliable) 7 vs AC; 2d10+4    SecondWind (minor; encounter)Monsters  Level 2 Soldier    Stats: HP 37; AC 18; Healing Surges 1    BasicAttack (standard; at-will) 9 vs AC; 1d10+2    Attack (standard; encounter) 9 vs AC; 2d10+2[/code][/sblock][sblock=Statistics][code]Fights simulated: 1000Avg rounds (per combat): 6.7  2  (2.8%): =========  3  (5.0%): =======  4 (14.1%): ================================  5 (30.4%): =========================================================  6 (49.4%): ===================================================================  7 (66.8%): =============================================================  8 (81.8%): =====================================================  9 (90.8%): =============================== 10 (95.9%): ================== 11 (98.4%): ======== 12 (99.3%): === 13 (99.8%): = 14(100.0%):  16(100.0%): Avg combats survived in a day (fights survived): 2.4  0 (15.0%): =================================================  1 (35.3%): ===================================================================  2 (53.6%): ============================================================  3 (69.8%): =====================================================  4 (87.2%): =========================================================  5 (95.2%): ==========================  6 (99.2%): =============  7(100.0%): ==Avg percentage of dailies used per day: 84.7[/code][/sblock]Level 1 Dwarf Defensive Fighter VS. Level 3 Soldier[sblock=Combatants][code]PCs  Level 1 Dwarf Defensive Fighter    Stats: HP 32; AC 19; Healing Surges 10    ReapingStrike (standard; at-will) 7 vs AC; 1d10+4; Miss: 2 damage    Attack (standard; encounter) 7 vs AC; 2d10+4    ComebackStrike (standard; daily; reliable) 7 vs AC; 2d10+4    SecondWind (minor; encounter)Monsters  Level 3 Soldier    Stats: HP 45; AC 19; Healing Surges 1    BasicAttack (standard; at-will) 10 vs AC; 1d10+3    Attack (standard; encounter) 10 vs AC; 2d10+3[/code][/sblock][sblock=Statistics][code]Fights simulated: 1000Avg rounds (per combat): 7.4  2  (0.6%): ==  3  (1.5%): ===  4  (6.7%): ==================  5 (19.4%): ==============================================  6 (37.7%): ===================================================================  7 (55.2%): ================================================================  8 (71.8%): =============================================================  9 (84.1%): ============================================ 10 (92.2%): ============================== 11 (96.3%): =============== 12 (98.4%): ======= 13 (99.4%): === 14 (99.7%): = 15 (99.9%):  19(100.0%): Avg combats survived in a day (fights survived): 0.9  0 (43.1%): ===================================================================  1 (77.1%): ====================================================  2 (91.7%): ======================  3 (97.5%): =========  4 (99.9%): ===  5(100.0%): Avg percentage of dailies used per day: 75.7[/code][/sblock]Level 1 Dwarf Defensive Fighter VS. Level 4 Soldier[sblock=Combatants][code]PCs  Level 1 Dwarf Defensive Fighter    Stats: HP 32; AC 19; Healing Surges 10    ReapingStrike (standard; at-will) 7 vs AC; 1d10+4; Miss: 2 damage    Attack (standard; encounter) 7 vs AC; 2d10+4    ComebackStrike (standard; daily; reliable) 7 vs AC; 2d10+4    SecondWind (minor; encounter)Monsters  Level 4 Soldier    Stats: HP 53; AC 20; Healing Surges 1    BasicAttack (standard; at-will) 11 vs AC; 1d10+3    Attack (standard; encounter) 11 vs AC; 2d10+3[/code][/sblock][sblock=Statistics][code]Fights simulated: 1000Avg rounds (per combat): 7.9  2  (0.1%):   3  (0.2%):   4  (4.0%): ===============  5 (13.9%): ========================================  6 (29.5%): ===============================================================  7 (45.7%): ==================================================================  8 (62.0%): ===================================================================  9 (76.9%): ============================================================= 10 (87.8%): ============================================ 11 (94.7%): ============================ 12 (97.2%): ========== 13 (98.8%): ====== 14 (99.4%): == 15 (99.9%): = 16 (99.9%):  17(100.0%): Avg combats survived in a day (fights survived): 0.4  0 (65.1%): ===================================================================  1 (94.8%): ==============================  2 (99.4%): ====  3 (99.9%):   5(100.0%): Avg percentage of dailies used per day: 70.7[/code][/sblock]Level 1 Dwarf Defensive Fighter VS. Level 5 Soldier[sblock=Combatants][code]PCs  Level 1 Dwarf Defensive Fighter    Stats: HP 32; AC 19; Healing Surges 10    ReapingStrike (standard; at-will) 7 vs AC; 1d10+4; Miss: 2 damage    Attack (standard; encounter) 7 vs AC; 2d10+4    ComebackStrike (standard; daily; reliable) 7 vs AC; 2d10+4    SecondWind (minor; encounter)Monsters  Level 5 Soldier    Stats: HP 61; AC 21; Healing Surges 1    BasicAttack (standard; at-will) 12 vs AC; 1d10+4    Attack (standard; encounter) 12 vs AC; 2d10+4[/code][/sblock][sblock=Statistics][code]Fights simulated: 1000Avg rounds (per combat): 7.4  3  (0.1%):   4  (6.8%): ======================  5 (20.4%): =============================================  6 (37.3%): =========================================================  7 (57.3%): ===================================================================  8 (72.6%): ===================================================  9 (83.6%): ==================================== 10 (91.5%): ========================== 11 (96.0%): =============== 12 (98.1%): ======= 13 (99.3%): === 14 (99.6%): = 15 (99.9%):  16(100.0%): Avg combats survived in a day (fights survived): 0.1  0 (88.7%): ===================================================================  1 (99.9%): ========  2(100.0%): Avg percentage of dailies used per day: 59.9[/code][/sblock][/sblock]Note that, for the time being, Truename's simulator is much better for this analysis than mine.</blockquote>

Verification