Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Mistwell" data-source="post: 3352071" data-attributes="member: 2525">By your logic, if I have protection from good on my domain spell list, then if I prepare it in a non-domain spell slot, I cannot swap that spell out for a cure spell.&nbsp; Why?&nbsp; Because it's considered a domain spell even it isn't prepared in a domain slot, and domain spells cannot be swapped out for cure spells.&nbsp; However, you and I both know that isn't how the game functions.&nbsp; You don't keep track of both domain slot spells and any spell that might be on a domain spell list but which is prepared in a regular slot, for purposes of what can be swapped.All the wording on page 32 of the PHB backs up the argument that a domain spell is a spell cast from a domain spell slot.&nbsp; The wording in the glossary does as well.&nbsp; And the wording of the page 31 PHB footnote does as well.&nbsp; And logic does as well for purposes of the debate over this prestige class.If you think your interpretation and the competing one are both reasonable, and one results in the prestige class being significantly more powerful than the other, and you already think the prestige class is very powerful, then logic dictates you choose the reasonable interpretation that grants less power for the already &quot;overpowered&quot; prestige class.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Mistwell, post: 3352071, member: 2525"] By your logic, if I have protection from good on my domain spell list, then if I prepare it in a non-domain spell slot, I cannot swap that spell out for a cure spell. Why? Because it's considered a domain spell even it isn't prepared in a domain slot, and domain spells cannot be swapped out for cure spells. However, you and I both know that isn't how the game functions. You don't keep track of both domain slot spells and any spell that might be on a domain spell list but which is prepared in a regular slot, for purposes of what can be swapped. All the wording on page 32 of the PHB backs up the argument that a domain spell is a spell cast from a domain spell slot. The wording in the glossary does as well. And the wording of the page 31 PHB footnote does as well. And logic does as well for purposes of the debate over this prestige class. If you think your interpretation and the competing one are both reasonable, and one results in the prestige class being significantly more powerful than the other, and you already think the prestige class is very powerful, then logic dictates you choose the reasonable interpretation that grants less power for the already "overpowered" prestige class. [/QUOTE]

Verification