Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Felix" data-source="post: 3353916" data-attributes="member: 3929">Would you do me the favor of citing those passages which support your claim, or list the post numbers that I may find where you cite them?Lack of evidence?Posts #103 and 104 cite you pages 31 and 32 in the PHB where the one extra spell clerics gain as a "domain spell". Does this not constitue evidence?Similarly, Mistwell's argument that because a spell is on a domain list, and therefore by your reasoning would always and everywhere qualify as a domain spell, this prepared spell would not be able to be spontaneously converted into a Cure or Inflict. Would you not agree that this is consistent with your argument? And if it is consistent with your argument, do you rule clerics with the Protection domain who prepare a Protection from Evil in a non-domain spell slot may not spontaneously convert that spell into a Cure Light Wounds? If this is not how you rule, how do you reconcile your two rulings?There is a contradiction between the glossary and the text on this issue only if you rule that  the "domain spell" title is applied to any spell on a domain list regardless of its appearance on the Cleric spell list as well.In such a case where there is a contradiction with one ruling and no contradiction with another, does this not support the ruling that lacks the contradiction?</blockquote>