Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Pergentile" data-source="post: 5562258" data-attributes="member: 6671368">So this is NOT going to be a whole new D20 system, since it will use 3.5 material... it will simply be an alternate version of 3.5. THAT makes me leery.There are VERY powerful cards that are not Legendary, and many Legendary cards that have little to no power OR flavor. To base the availability of them simply based on them having the &quot;Legendary&quot; type, seems a bit... ignorant of both D&amp;D and MtG.In the end, since a &quot;Planeswalker&quot; could easily be made in D&amp;D following the current rules... and almost every creature and spell in MtG could be easily (if slowly) converted into D&amp;D, I really think any rules changes/bastardization of the 3.5 edition would ruin itself.I would personally suggest simply doing those easy but time-consuming conversions and simply making a 3.5 edition book of extra content from MtG, assuming one knows well how to make monsters, spells, etc. for 3.5 edition.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Pergentile, post: 5562258, member: 6671368"] So this is NOT going to be a whole new D20 system, since it will use 3.5 material... it will simply be an alternate version of 3.5. THAT makes me leery. There are VERY powerful cards that are not Legendary, and many Legendary cards that have little to no power OR flavor. To base the availability of them simply based on them having the "Legendary" type, seems a bit... ignorant of both D&D and MtG. In the end, since a "Planeswalker" could easily be made in D&D following the current rules... and almost every creature and spell in MtG could be easily (if slowly) converted into D&D, I really think any rules changes/bastardization of the 3.5 edition would ruin itself. I would personally suggest simply doing those easy but time-consuming conversions and simply making a 3.5 edition book of extra content from MtG, assuming one knows well how to make monsters, spells, etc. for 3.5 edition. [/QUOTE]

Verification