Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="kitcik" data-source="post: 5565629" data-attributes="member: 98256">Two points, plus a bonus point, then I am going to hibernate until the rules are at least "set in stone" since it doesn't seem like we are talking about a game at this point, just an idea.1 - I remember when I was a kid and I received a 3-pack of card games: Old Maid, Go Fish and Crazy Eights. A couple of weeks after I got it, I realized (as do all kids) that I could play any of the games with any of the decks as long as I thought about it. So, it was cool to play Old Maid with the Crazy Eights deck. After a while, we realized that it was actually better to play Old Maid with the Old Maid deck because playing it with the Crazy Eights deck only slowed things down and there really was no point to it. So far, this feels to me like you have created a Magic variant that you are for some unknown reason jamming into a D&D crust. Wouldn't it be better just to play this game with the cards?2 - When you are taking all the combos in the 3.5 universe and multiplying them by all the combos in the history of MTG, a 10-man playtest group is not only not impressive, it is absolutely inadequate. You have a large playtest group available right here, we just need the rules and a chance to make input BEFORE they are "set in stone." Oh well...Bonus - Your "I'm not gonna go there... but I played with so and so whose picture is ON a Magic card" was friggin hilarious! I will give you that. I played at Neutral Ground with Finkel, OMS, Zvi, etc. before you even heard of the game. I have at least one copy of every Magic card ever printed sitting within 5 feet of me right now. I played with Richard Garfield for goodness sake. I could go on, but I don't really care who has the most MTG experience - I just find it funny that when I questioned your experience you got so defensive you went on for two posts. And you are running the company? Uh oh...</blockquote>

Verification