Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Christian" data-source="post: 275114" data-attributes="member: 381">Well, I'll try to beat the pileup and get everything out front ...Group A: &quot;The PH text (that Hong quoted above) is perfectly clear-even with Combat Reflexes, one character can't get more than one AoO on a given opponent in one round.&quot;Group B: &quot;But the example is of a goblin passing by who exits more than one threatened space during&nbsp; his move. It's not clear to me that this extends to a situation where the goblin moves through your threatened area, stops, drinks a potion within your threat range, and then tries to disarm you.&quot;Group A: &quot;Oh, come on.&quot;Group B: &quot;I'm serious!&quot;Group A: &quot;Crazy munchkin.&quot;Group B: &quot;Dumb rules-lawyer.&quot;OK, now that that's out of the way: To answer the original question, I don't know that any published Sage response (etc.) addressed this questions. Individuals have written the Sage and gotten responses consistent with the Group A interpretation, which have resulted in derision of the Sage by Group B and not much else. So, there you go.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Christian, post: 275114, member: 381"] Well, I'll try to beat the pileup and get everything out front ... Group A: "The PH text (that Hong quoted above) is perfectly clear-even with Combat Reflexes, one character can't get more than one AoO on a given opponent in one round." Group B: "But the example is of a goblin passing by who exits more than one threatened space during his move. It's not clear to me that this extends to a situation where the goblin moves through your threatened area, stops, drinks a potion within your threat range, and then tries to disarm you." Group A: "Oh, come on." Group B: "I'm serious!" Group A: "Crazy munchkin." Group B: "Dumb rules-lawyer." OK, now that that's out of the way: To answer the original question, I don't know that any published Sage response (etc.) addressed this questions. Individuals have written the Sage and gotten responses consistent with the Group A interpretation, which have resulted in derision of the Sage by Group B and not much else. So, there you go. [/QUOTE]

Verification