Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="ruleslawyer" data-source="post: 2633284" data-attributes="member: 1757">'Cause I feel like causing trouble:Since I missed this the first time (and can't find it), I was wondering if we might have a *civil* discussion on the matter (since judging from De Big Rules Monkey's tone, said discussion may have been less than such last time around). Here's my problem:The distinction between "different attributes of the same spell" and "same attributes of the base spell" does not appear in any of the above-mentioned feats. Why, therefore, should a Twinned, Maximized fireball NOT produce two maximized fireballs? There is a clear rule stated in the specific case of Empower + Maximize, but not anywhere else. Moreover, the entire Maximize/other feat problem really only seems to apply in the case of two specific feats (Twin and Repeat). Finally, does it really make sense that doubling a spell's effect (via Twin Spell) and doubling the radius of the spell (via Widen), which in many cases equates to "doubling a spell's effect," would be affected differently by Maximize or Empower?Just musing, but would welcome input.</blockquote>