Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Hawken" data-source="post: 5064740" data-attributes="member: 23619">Nonsi, regarding your 'finger pointing' nonsense, I don't call it like I see it, I call it like it is. And there's nothing wrong with finger pointing when its done to point out obvious flaws, mistakes, invalid points, etc.. I'm the last person on this entire forum to fall in line with any PC bull crap. And you have yet to deny or refute any of that finger pointing I did. Show me where any of those are wrong.You admit (maybe sarcastically, but for the sake of this point, I'll go with genuinely) that you don't understand the book. If you don't understand something you cannot offer any valid criticism or complaint of it, and you especially can't offer any reasonable fixes. What you're doing is like saying Shakespeare sucks but you've got an idea for a better story after you've only read the Cliff Notes and not the actual material. Didn't state that. But like I mentioned above, you have no valid disagreement on a subject you don't understand. If you don't understand something, disagreeing with it or calling it wrong is an emotional response, subjective, and thus neither objective nor logical. If you need an example of how worthless subjective opinions are when it comes to facts, watch just about anything on MSNBC and you'll get the idea. I didn't respond to all of your points because many of them were covered already and you're just stubbornly refusing to acknowledge the information in front of you and how it can be applied to your games. You accuse the authors of not providing enough information and seem to hold some contempt for them writing a book not up to your standards (whatever those may be), but your opinion is in the very tiny minority in that regard, for you and your hundreds of people that don't get it are vastly outnumbered by the thousands that do. If you need help understanding the books, find someone that does understand and ask them to explain it. That's not what this forum is for. Neither is this a forum for whining or complaining about the authors of 3rd edition because their material is not to your satisfaction. Until you get the gist of the 3.5 rules, any house rule you create is innately flawed by your incomplete understanding of what it is you're trying to fix or improve.</blockquote>

Verification