Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Spatula" data-source="post: 5599616" data-attributes="member: 2198">Was this email from the "another player" mentioned previously, or the DM? Your post is not clear to me on that account.You're not wrong, according the rules. The email, if real, is definitely very over the top. Since weapons mainly exist to be used in attacks, using a weapon from the rule book to make an attack is certainly not cheesy. What else would improvised weapons be used for? Now, whether the rock in question qualifies as an improvised weapon or not is up to the DM.And of course, a battleaxe would do 1d10+Str damage, with an extra +2 to hit, plus bonuses from magic or feats, etc. Which is probably a lot better for your fighter than 1d4+Dex damage with no to-hit bonus.Now, you and/or the emailer may have handled the situation poorly from a social perspective...</blockquote>