Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="ThirdWizard" data-source="post: 2122601" data-attributes="member: 12037">NOT asking &quot;Okay if I wish for this then what will happen.&quot; But, &quot;Can a wish alter a spell I have forever?&quot; My personal answer would be, &quot;No, you cannot do that.&quot; And, I think that a player should have that information.But, see, there are DMs out there who will, no matter what you wish for, make something horrible happen to your PC. This is a &quot;mother may I&quot; situation. If I take dragon as my favored enemy is it wasted? If I take an item creation feat will I have the downtime to use it? If I make a wish how powerful do you think the spell is? The answer could be anywhere from &quot;Only what is listed&quot; to &quot;It can bend the Multiverse to its will.&quot; This is important!I think a player has a right to know a DM's feeling on particular spells, especially when the spells are so subjective as a wish. There are many many subjectivities involved in a D&amp;D game and I think it is imperitive that a DM and Player be on the same page and have the same expectatons on how the game will work. If a Player has been with a DM who allowed various wishes for years then goes to a new game, I believe that the DM should be upfront on how he or she approaches this, and many many other issues, in the game.And it isn't Piffle, its Pfil! <img src="https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/joypixels/assets/8.0/png/unicode/64/1f60e.png" class="smilie smilie--emoji" loading="lazy" width="64" height="64" alt=":cool:" title="Cool&nbsp; &nbsp; :cool:"&nbsp; data-smilie="6"data-shortname=":cool:" /></blockquote>

[QUOTE="ThirdWizard, post: 2122601, member: 12037"] NOT asking "Okay if I wish for this then what will happen." But, "Can a wish alter a spell I have forever?" My personal answer would be, "No, you cannot do that." And, I think that a player should have that information. But, see, there are DMs out there who will, no matter what you wish for, make something horrible happen to your PC. This is a "mother may I" situation. If I take dragon as my favored enemy is it wasted? If I take an item creation feat will I have the downtime to use it? If I make a [i]wish [/i]how powerful do you think the spell is? The answer could be anywhere from "Only what is listed" to "It can bend the Multiverse to its will." This is important! I think a player has a right to know a DM's feeling on particular spells, especially when the spells are so subjective as a [i]wish[/i]. There are many many subjectivities involved in a D&D game and I think it is imperitive that a DM and Player be on the same page and have the same expectatons on how the game will work. If a Player has been with a DM who allowed various [i]wish[/i]es for years then goes to a new game, I believe that the DM should be upfront on how he or she approaches this, and many many other issues, in the game. And it isn't Piffle, its Pfil! :cool: [/QUOTE]

Verification