Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Dannyalcatraz" data-source="post: 4581260" data-attributes="member: 19675">andI noted that myself in previous posts.But you should note the original question specifically asked about a human with MG wielding a ranseur- a 2 handed reach weapon (the questioner was either unconcerned about or ignorant of the existence of reach weapons like the whip).&nbsp; Without MG or PB, he couldn't wield such a weapon at all, as the Sage noted.With MG or PB, he can wield the weapon normally, which would include Reach.He never specifically addressed MG or PB because at least one of those was mentioned specifically in the question, which provides the context for his musing on how a M character would use an overized reach weapon.&nbsp; His answer's mere existence implies consideration of the question's language, and against the backdrop of the question, he is obviously considering MG and probably PB as well.At any rate, we're now discussing this in circles, neither convincing the other.&nbsp; The point remains, however, that there are 2 different schools of thought on the matter, and the OP should pick one consistently apply it.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Dannyalcatraz, post: 4581260, member: 19675"] and I noted that myself in previous posts. But [B]you[/B] should note the original question[I] specifically [/I]asked about a human with MG wielding a ranseur- a 2 handed reach weapon (the questioner was either unconcerned about or ignorant of the existence of reach weapons like the whip). Without MG or PB, he couldn't wield such a weapon at all, as the Sage noted. With MG or PB, he can wield the weapon normally, which would include Reach. He never specifically addressed MG or PB because at least one of those was mentioned specifically in the question, which provides the context for his musing on how a M character would use an overized reach weapon. His answer's mere existence implies consideration of the question's language, and against the backdrop of the question, he is obviously considering MG and probably PB as well. At any rate, we're now discussing this in circles, neither convincing the other. The point remains, however, that there are 2 different schools of thought on the matter, and the OP should pick one consistently apply it. [/QUOTE]

Verification