Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="photon1966" data-source="post: 270544" data-attributes="member: 1575">Well i would have ruled that the water would have doused the fire.&nbsp; Why it did is because the Alchemists fire to my recall is a paste and sticks to the target and if doused with water would have not spread but been drenched, and snuffed out any flame.&nbsp; Maybe, MAYBE... the flames would still have been present but it's only a 5x5 area if I recall corectly.&nbsp; The whole area is wet, people are there from what it sounds like, who can stamp out the flames, pull out cloaks or sleeping rolls, etc. The Purify would not have helped in my opinion.&nbsp; The spell does not separate the two but removes it, and the water is all over the floor, so what area are you purifying and then the toxins are really in the water but rather below or on top of it, not part of it technically.&nbsp; If this was in a container of sorts then yes I think it would work.But otherwise still very inventive, but maybe the gm should have come up with a better method to acheive his ends.&nbsp; What was all the old furniture made of?&nbsp; Oil soaked wicker?Just my thoughts.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="photon1966, post: 270544, member: 1575"] Well i would have ruled that the water would have doused the fire. Why it did is because the Alchemists fire to my recall is a paste and sticks to the target and if doused with water would have not spread but been drenched, and snuffed out any flame. Maybe, MAYBE... the flames would still have been present but it's only a 5x5 area if I recall corectly. The whole area is wet, people are there from what it sounds like, who can stamp out the flames, pull out cloaks or sleeping rolls, etc. The Purify would not have helped in my opinion. The spell does not separate the two but removes it, and the water is all over the floor, so what area are you purifying and then the toxins are really in the water but rather below or on top of it, not part of it technically. If this was in a container of sorts then yes I think it would work. But otherwise still very inventive, but maybe the gm should have come up with a better method to acheive his ends. What was all the old furniture made of? Oil soaked wicker? Just my thoughts. [/QUOTE]

Verification