Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Deadguy" data-source="post: 48191" data-attributes="member: 2480">Player A - Not Unreasonable?I am with Tonguez on this one. When I read your description, the same thought went through my head: a Bluff attempt to confuse and disturb the Leader. But the only person who can really tell you the reason is Player A and you should speak to her before forming judgements of the wisdom of her character's actions.Note also that she was very concerned to save the girl, being prepared to take AoO's in order to help her. Incidentally, the Leader's action was a Coup de Grace, and if you'd wanted to, you could have resolved it that way.At the last though, ask yourself: are you just a little sore that the player acted in a way you didn't think was appropriate, or didn't really allow for? It's very easy as DM to work out the 'right answer' to the situations you create (and boy, do I know that as a DM myself!), and feel cheated if the players do something quite different.But I reiterate, you really need to speak with the player in private, to get this resolved.</blockquote>