Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Scribble" data-source="post: 5669757" data-attributes="member: 23977">I have to say I'm one of those DMs that tends to only have people roll after they tell me what they're doing. I like a sort of combo of the two ideas, which I think is why the system Mearls has been describing has been growing on me.I think a lot of your experience really has to do with what kind of DM you faced back in the day, and I think that could be summed up by asking... What happened if you ever cast the spell Wish or&nbsp; found a ring of wishes?Did you DM look at your wish and provided it wasn't too far out into crazyland let it be granted as requested?orDid your DM look at every wish no matter how small it was for an incredibly long time looking for any possible way he could read it to cause you the most suffering for ever having dared make it in the first place?If your DM was the later type you probably hate DM fiat, and love the idea of skill points and dice rolling.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Scribble, post: 5669757, member: 23977"] I have to say I'm one of those DMs that tends to only have people roll after they tell me what they're doing. I like a sort of combo of the two ideas, which I think is why the system Mearls has been describing has been growing on me. I think a lot of your experience really has to do with what kind of DM you faced back in the day, and I think that could be summed up by asking... What happened if you ever cast the spell Wish or found a ring of wishes? Did you DM look at your wish and provided it wasn't too far out into crazyland let it be granted as requested? or Did your DM look at every wish no matter how small it was for an incredibly long time looking for any possible way he could read it to cause you the most suffering for ever having dared make it in the first place? If your DM was the later type you probably hate DM fiat, and love the idea of skill points and dice rolling. [/QUOTE]

Verification