Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Merlion" data-source="post: 1445266" data-attributes="member: 10397">Ok first right off the bat i want to say I really apreciate your feedback, its polite, and detailed, and you actualy give extensive reasons for your opnions. However, I do disagree on numerous points, but i dont want you to take my responses negatively, because they are not meant so. This is the first disagreement. I, obviously, have no problem with it. And indeed, 2 our of 3 of thease races I would disgaree that they are "the best" for any given thing. I can see it with thease guys tho. Every race in the PH gets either low light, or darkvision, save humans and halflings. I'm mostly just following trend. Yes. Really, I can see there being a goodly contigent of knowledgble Rogues amongest the Emrudin. I added comprehend langauges because its knowledge-gaining related. I couldnt really come up with another fitting cantrip or 1st level divination spell. I dont really think it detracts that much from langauges as it doesnt allow 2 way communication..and its only once a day and short duration. Well, again pretty much every race gets 2 or 3 skill bonuses, and I dont know any logical reason for them to have bonuses to any other skills. Well, Gather Information would perhaps make some sense, and/or Decipher Script. You later idea of Concentration isnt bad either. However from a flavour/RP perspective, it really makes a lot more sense for them to have bonuses to knowledge skills, so this is something I will have to think about. These 3 races have the ability score adjustments they do for very specfic reasons. Well, for a very specfic reason. You've got the 3 mind stats, and the 3 body stats. I see them in a sort of oposing fashion...Str/Int Wis/Dex Cha/Con. thats why thease races have the adjustments they do. And since I am pretty sure they are mechanicaly balanced in this respect, I am unlikely to change it. I would not object to this. No on the stealth..thats not the right image for them. But I may replace the Spellcraft bonus with a Concentration bonus. I like the idea of the +1 save versus magic very much, but i like the divination thing too that one is tough.</blockquote>

Verification