Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="gban007" data-source="post: 9491381" data-attributes="member: 56488">while I don't have a problem with the changes Villenueve made, I'm not sure he achieved this part that well, or at least he triggered an abrupt change.&nbsp; There seemed to be a pivot point after the Harkonnens raided that Femen home, where the Fremen wanted him to go south but he didn't want to because of the visions he saw of what what happen if he did.&nbsp; At that point it appeared Chani was helping pressure him to go south, so when he made the decision it wasn't so much a desire for power as such. It is only after going south and taking the water of life he seems to switch to that desire for power, and we see less from his perspective from that point.&nbsp; So it is a bit blurred, leaving it a bit ambiguous like the books in terms of his overall intent there, while I think making it more clear the bad steps he is taking and their consequences. ( in the book it seems less a desire for power vs a desire for revenge and not becoming a guild navigator).</blockquote>

[QUOTE="gban007, post: 9491381, member: 56488"] while I don't have a problem with the changes Villenueve made, I'm not sure he achieved this part that well, or at least he triggered an abrupt change. There seemed to be a pivot point after the Harkonnens raided that Femen home, where the Fremen wanted him to go south but he didn't want to because of the visions he saw of what what happen if he did. At that point it appeared Chani was helping pressure him to go south, so when he made the decision it wasn't so much a desire for power as such. It is only after going south and taking the water of life he seems to switch to that desire for power, and we see less from his perspective from that point. So it is a bit blurred, leaving it a bit ambiguous like the books in terms of his overall intent there, while I think making it more clear the bad steps he is taking and their consequences. ( in the book it seems less a desire for power vs a desire for revenge and not becoming a guild navigator). [/QUOTE]

Verification