Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="ValhallaGH" data-source="post: 5022154" data-attributes="member: 41187">#1 This is a matter of style, especially the level of cinematic style in a particular game.  Regulating major failure to 'fumbles' makes it a matter of extreme (bad) luck, rather than a danger of attempting that which is beyond your skill.In the context of most of the d20 system, shifting "climber falls" to a fumble is appropriate.  Whether or not it is a desirable shift depends upon the style and tone of a particular table's version of d20.Also, take a look at Disable Device and Swim, which also use the 'fail by 5+' mechanic.#2 Yes, this is a good mechanic.  I especially like how you applied it to jump, thereby normalizing one of the least predictable skills.  Also, it makes the skill a good bit saner, where characters can't be setting world records at fifth level.Taking 10 is still really useful, since it can get you a basic success and avoid any potential of failure.  In the Jump example, taking 10 gets a 19 -> 13', which is a good jump (if not the character's best possible) and well within range of clinging to the ledge.#3 Gather Information.  Disable Device (disabling parts of traps, but not other parts, leaving some danger; bonus, the base DC can come down a bit).  Knowledge (which is already there, as you noted).</blockquote>