Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Rangoric" data-source="post: 3715683" data-attributes="member: 54530">Exactly my point.&nbsp; You are argueing that NO game is a Role-Playing Game unless the certain instance of it being played is an RPG.As such you cannot say that D&amp;D is a role-playing game, just as you also can't say NWN is not a role playing game.All your criterea are outside the box so to speak, and as such eliminate the game as a point of reference.&nbsp; In no instance has your decision for a game be a role-playing game based on the game itself, only what was going on in the game.Page number please?&nbsp; I don't play the basic game.&nbsp; I have a PHB and DMG and MM that have no reference to this.The basic game has &quot;An Adventure&quot;.&nbsp; This &quot;Adventure&quot; is set up for 2-5 people overall to play.My PHB (which is 1 of the 3 books I require to play the game page 5 PHB under the heading &quot;What you Need to Play&quot;) makes no mention of these other people, just that a group of people play (I by myself am a group of 1).Really, your arguement also says that if you have 6 people you aren't playing D&amp;D anymore.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Rangoric, post: 3715683, member: 54530"] Exactly my point. You are argueing that NO game is a Role-Playing Game unless the certain instance of it being played is an RPG. As such you cannot say that D&D is a role-playing game, just as you also can't say NWN is not a role playing game. All your criterea are outside the box so to speak, and as such eliminate the game as a point of reference. [i]In no instance has your decision for a game be a role-playing game based on the game itself, only what was going on in the game[/i]. Page number please? I don't play the basic game. I have a PHB and DMG and MM that have no reference to this. The basic game has "An Adventure". This "Adventure" is set up for 2-5 people overall to play. My PHB (which is 1 of the 3 books I require to play the game page 5 PHB under the heading "What you Need to Play") makes no mention of these other people, just that a group of people play (I by myself am a group of 1). Really, your arguement also says that if you have 6 people you aren't playing D&D anymore. [/QUOTE]

Verification