Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Celebrim" data-source="post: 6695658" data-attributes="member: 4937">Err... I'm trying to get my head around whatever twisted logic gets you to believe that, and I'm not getting it.&nbsp; So basically you are saying that because carting treasure out of a dungeon made you powerful, that greed is good?&nbsp;&nbsp; You do realize that nothing in the rules requires you to keep any of that treasure.&nbsp; Indeed, many classes were required to give at least some of it away, and notably the Paladin had to give a portion of it away and the other explicitly good class the Ranger had to give away all of their excess.So, yeah, I don't get where you are coming from at all.&nbsp; There doesn't even seem to be a tissue of logic here.Err... Sex is definitely not evil in the above definitions.&nbsp; In fact, sex is inferred to be good, but on the whole is generally not discussed except to point out explicitly that when people conflate sin with a sexual act they are misled or thinking unwisely.&nbsp; So, did you even read the definition?&nbsp;&nbsp; I no more claim that sex is evil than I do material possessions, food, or alcohol is evil.&nbsp; Indeed, again, it is inferred that all of those things are actually good.Oh well.&nbsp; I'll have to have patience for the both of us then.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Celebrim, post: 6695658, member: 4937"] Err... I'm trying to get my head around whatever twisted logic gets you to believe that, and I'm not getting it. So basically you are saying that because carting treasure out of a dungeon made you powerful, that greed is good? You do realize that nothing in the rules requires you to keep any of that treasure. Indeed, many classes were required to give at least some of it away, and notably the Paladin had to give a portion of it away and the other explicitly good class the Ranger had to give away all of their excess. So, yeah, I don't get where you are coming from at all. There doesn't even seem to be a tissue of logic here. Err... Sex is definitely not evil in the above definitions. In fact, sex is inferred to be good, but on the whole is generally not discussed except to point out explicitly that when people conflate sin with a sexual act they are misled or thinking unwisely. So, did you even read the definition? I no more claim that sex is evil than I do material possessions, food, or alcohol is evil. Indeed, again, it is inferred that all of those things are actually good. Oh well. I'll have to have patience for the both of us then. [/QUOTE]

Verification