Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Dancer" data-source="post: 1947242" data-attributes="member: 15522">Do dopplegangers have any legal rights in your world?&nbsp; I'm assuming they do, since they were arrested.&nbsp; If so, the rogue and the dwarf should be tried for murder.The elven rogue appears to have just wanted to kill someone.&nbsp; Does he make a habit out of attempting to kill someone (or something) that merely impersonated his girl?&nbsp; That is the act of a psychopath and he probably shouldn't be running around loose in the city.The dwarf was just stupid.&nbsp; The weapon was already killing the doppleganger, why go and blatantly commit murder when he could have just stood by.&nbsp; The only reason I see is that the sorceress was trying to stop the murder and the dwarf wanted to make sure the creature died.&nbsp; Once again, the dwarf should be tried for murder.As for the alignment issues, one or two outbursts of craziness do not make for alignment changing circumstances but if they continue in this vein then yeah, you should give them warnings and then start shifting alignments.Also, about giving and keeping one's word.&nbsp; If the monk gave his word and the rest of the party seemed to go along with it then they all gave their word.&nbsp; Someone posted that giving one's word to a duplicitous foe means you don't have to keep it.&nbsp; That's true if you are without honor.&nbsp; Honorless players will hopefully eventually get to someone who will not accept their word because they are known to break it.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Dancer, post: 1947242, member: 15522"] Do dopplegangers have any legal rights in your world? I'm assuming they do, since they were arrested. If so, the rogue and the dwarf should be tried for murder. The elven rogue appears to have just wanted to kill someone. Does he make a habit out of attempting to kill someone (or something) that merely impersonated his girl? That is the act of a psychopath and he probably shouldn't be running around loose in the city. The dwarf was just stupid. The weapon was already killing the doppleganger, why go and blatantly commit murder when he could have just stood by. The only reason I see is that the sorceress was trying to stop the murder and the dwarf wanted to make sure the creature died. Once again, the dwarf should be tried for murder. As for the alignment issues, one or two outbursts of craziness do not make for alignment changing circumstances but if they continue in this vein then yeah, you should give them warnings and then start shifting alignments. Also, about giving and keeping one's word. If the monk gave his word and the rest of the party seemed to go along with it then they all gave their word. Someone posted that giving one's word to a duplicitous foe means you don't have to keep it. That's true if you are without honor. Honorless players will hopefully eventually get to someone who will not accept their word because they are known to break it. [/QUOTE]

Verification