Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Lonely Tylenol" data-source="post: 3316467" data-attributes="member: 18549">Actually, last time I checked, killing innocent people was evil, regardless of your motives for doing so.&nbsp; If you kill people because you like to, it's evil.&nbsp; If you kill people because you're crazy, it's evil.&nbsp; The act is evil, and perpetrating the act means that you are committing evil.&nbsp; If performing such acts becomes typical for you, you become evil.Your reasons for performing evil are immaterial.&nbsp; What counts is that you did the evil act.I agree that she had reason to believe that something was up.&nbsp; I said so myself.&nbsp; But she made up the whole conspiracy as an excuse to commit murder because at that moment she felt like murdering someone.&nbsp; There was no evidence that any of what she made up was going on.&nbsp; The sequence of events she describes is completely her invention, and does not correspond to the evidence that was presented to her.&quot;Not that far fetched&quot; is not sufficient to justify murder.Shojo was not a paladin, and so had not made the same vows that the paladins had.Agreed.&nbsp; No one is arguing otherwise.&nbsp; What is this intended to address?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Lonely Tylenol, post: 3316467, member: 18549"] Actually, last time I checked, killing innocent people was evil, regardless of your motives for doing so. If you kill people because you like to, it's evil. If you kill people because you're crazy, it's evil. The act is evil, and perpetrating the act means that you are committing evil. If performing such acts becomes typical for you, you become evil. Your reasons for performing evil are immaterial. What counts is that you did the evil act. I agree that she had reason to believe that something was up. I said so myself. But she made up the whole conspiracy as an excuse to commit murder because at that moment she felt like murdering someone. There was no evidence that any of what she made up was going on. The sequence of events she describes is completely her invention, and does not correspond to the evidence that was presented to her. "Not that far fetched" is not sufficient to justify murder. Shojo was not a paladin, and so had not made the same vows that the paladins had. Agreed. No one is arguing otherwise. What is this intended to address? [/QUOTE]

Verification