Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="schporto" data-source="post: 3019812" data-attributes="member: 5967">My suggestions for categories (to deal with the large books) would be:Adventures:&nbsp; Anything that characters are expected to gain 5 or fewer levels.Campaigns:&nbsp; Large adventures where characters are expected to gain more than 5 levels.Campaign Settings:&nbsp; Large books that may contain adventures, or not.So ( I own none of these but am basing this sorting on what I've read about them)Shackled City == CampaignPotolus == Campaign Setting DCC #35 == Campaign SettingMost other DCC stuff == AdventureRappan Atthauk == CampaignThe other bits:1.&nbsp; I think the nomination of judges has mostly worked. The voting for the judges is a really good ieda.2.&nbsp; Keep the d20 category.4.&nbsp; I kinda like this idea for a split, it means that something like a tshirt won't win over a dm screen.&nbsp; And the judges won't have to consider which is better of those two - I mean how the heck do you compare them...6.&nbsp; As for the evaluation methods - I'm not sure how things are evaluated right now.-cpd-cpd</blockquote>

[QUOTE="schporto, post: 3019812, member: 5967"] My suggestions for categories (to deal with the large books) would be: Adventures: Anything that characters are expected to gain 5 or fewer levels. Campaigns: Large adventures where characters are expected to gain more than 5 levels. Campaign Settings: Large books that may contain adventures, or not. So ( I own none of these but am basing this sorting on what I've read about them) Shackled City == Campaign Potolus == Campaign Setting DCC #35 == Campaign Setting Most other DCC stuff == Adventure Rappan Atthauk == Campaign The other bits: 1. I think the nomination of judges has mostly worked. The voting for the judges is a really good ieda. 2. Keep the d20 category. 4. I kinda like this idea for a split, it means that something like a tshirt won't win over a dm screen. And the judges won't have to consider which is better of those two - I mean how the heck do you compare them... 6. As for the evaluation methods - I'm not sure how things are evaluated right now. -cpd -cpd [/QUOTE]

Verification