Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Rel" data-source="post: 90218" data-attributes="member: 99">I ran this adventure for a Rogue and a Barbarian.The first round the Rogue won the initiative and caught the Orc flat footed.&nbsp; He managed a Sneak Attack and killed the Orc.On his turn, the Barbarian Raged.&nbsp; Then the player told me he wanted to Sunder the Pie.&nbsp; I tried to explain that the Pie was an unattended object and not normally subject to the Sunder rules.&nbsp; Even if the Orc hadn't been killed, he was not occupying the same space as the Pie and therefore (as Shadowdancer astutely pointed out) didn't &quot;have&quot; the Pie.The player started to get angry that I had &quot;shafted&quot; Sunder.Rather than argue about it, I let the Barbarian have his way.&nbsp; He Sundered the Pie and ate his half of it the following round as a Move Equivalent Action.&nbsp; But I did get him back for his whining.Since the module didn't specify, it was a Rot Grub Pie.Maybe I should start a Story Hour thread about this adventure.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Rel, post: 90218, member: 99"] I ran this adventure for a Rogue and a Barbarian. The first round the Rogue won the initiative and caught the Orc flat footed. He managed a Sneak Attack and killed the Orc. On his turn, the Barbarian Raged. Then the player told me he wanted to Sunder the Pie. I tried to explain that the Pie was an unattended object and not normally subject to the Sunder rules. Even if the Orc hadn't been killed, he was not occupying the same space as the Pie and therefore (as Shadowdancer astutely pointed out) didn't "have" the Pie. The player started to get angry that I had "shafted" Sunder. Rather than argue about it, I let the Barbarian have his way. He Sundered the Pie and ate his half of it the following round as a Move Equivalent Action. But I did get him back for his whining. Since the module didn't specify, it was a Rot Grub Pie. Maybe I should start a Story Hour thread about this adventure. [/QUOTE]

Verification