Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Hussar" data-source="post: 4483361" data-attributes="member: 22779">But, a non-evil act would be perfectly acceptable to paladins, Storm Raven.&nbsp; They have no problems with you performing neutral acts.&nbsp; If this was a neutral or good act, then why would you have to lie about it to them?Same goes with Cadfan.&nbsp; The fact that the rightful ruler of the land is a few steps away means that &quot;frontier justice&quot; is pretty much pointless.&nbsp; Sure, the bad guy brags that he can get away with it, but, that doesn't mean he's right.Heck, Mr McEvil has Non-detection.&nbsp; Ok.&nbsp; V whacks him with dispel magics until he detects as evil (you do have a boat full of paladins after all) and then perform the trial.&nbsp; Poof, Mr Mc Evil gets to hang all nice and lawful. But, V isn't interested in that.&nbsp; He bypasses everything, pulls the trigger and murders the prisoner.&nbsp; I'm not saying V is evil.&nbsp; I am saying that he just committed an evil act.&nbsp; Good grief, does he need to eat puppies too?&nbsp; Permanently killing a prisoner is an evil act.&nbsp; Full stop.&nbsp; You cannot justify it at all.&nbsp; Not when the rightful ruler of the land is ten steps away, and there are perfectly reasonable ways of conducting a fair trial.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Hussar, post: 4483361, member: 22779"] But, a non-evil act would be perfectly acceptable to paladins, Storm Raven. They have no problems with you performing neutral acts. If this was a neutral or good act, then why would you have to lie about it to them? Same goes with Cadfan. The fact that the rightful ruler of the land is a few steps away means that "frontier justice" is pretty much pointless. Sure, the bad guy brags that he can get away with it, but, that doesn't mean he's right. Heck, Mr McEvil has Non-detection. Ok. V whacks him with dispel magics until he detects as evil (you do have a boat full of paladins after all) and then perform the trial. Poof, Mr Mc Evil gets to hang all nice and lawful. But, V isn't interested in that. He bypasses everything, pulls the trigger and murders the prisoner. I'm not saying V is evil. I am saying that he just committed an evil act. Good grief, does he need to eat puppies too? Permanently killing a prisoner is an evil act. Full stop. You cannot justify it at all. Not when the rightful ruler of the land is ten steps away, and there are perfectly reasonable ways of conducting a fair trial. [/QUOTE]

Verification