[OT] 5 Emotions

Azure Trance

First Post
I watched Vanilla Sky earlier tonight and Kurt Russell as a psychologist said that there were five emotions:

Guilt
Hate
Shame
Revenge
Love

Just curious if these really are the five basics, which would fit in nicely with five senses and five tastes.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Sounds like bollocks to me. What about

Jealousy
Happiness
Sadness
Regret
Nostalgia
Pride

let alone the biggest one of all....

FEAR
 
Last edited:





I'm not sure lust is an emotion.

And if there is a psychologist out there who really believes that there is only one positive emotion, I pitty them. No, actually they frighten me.
 

Buttercup said:
And if there is a psychologist out there who really believes that there is only one positive emotion, I pitty them. No, actually they frighten me.

What about people who think emotions aren't inherently good or bad? Anger and fear (two emotions that sound bad) can be very helpful.
 

There are many emotions to be experienced in life. Since I come from a physics background, I wonder if the more complex emotions can be represented by a combination of "atomic" emotions.

(as an aside, what is the root word that means "indivisible" is it atmos - where we get atomic or is it the word quanta/quantum ? maybe someone can answer that for me)

I have also run a game where the two main religions had the idea that emotions had opposites. The opposite of humility was pride and the opposite of love was fear.

I know that many would argue that the opposite of love is hate but I saw hate as a combination of fear and pain.

I definately agree that there are far more than five emotions, but I was wondering if there are primary emotions, like primary colours.

I would argue that hunger is a subset of desire (ie the desire for food).
Nostalgia would not be a primary emotion because it requires memory (memory is not an emotion but can you have nostalgia without memory ? )
Jealousy, lust and shame would not be primary because they need a focus. Jealousy over a thing, lust over a person and shame is pain/embarassment from a social situation and um, er, looks like this theory still needs some work.

Now I'm starting to really feel out of my depth (hehe, is it confusion or disorientation that is causing my discomfort ?).
 

Always_a_DM: Atom comes from the Greek a- (prefix used to make something negative) and tomos (basically, able to be cut). All your medical operations ending with -tomy (appendectomy) involve cutting out something.

Quantum (plural quanta) is Latin for "how much"; physicists used it in reference to energy coming in certain sized lumps.

On topic:
I'll agree with Buttercup; if there is only one positive emotion, we got problems. If you simplify things enough and twist them around, you could maybe end up with 5 emotions, but real life has many more than five.

I've felt that the real opposite of love is selfishness. Those of you familiar with I Corinthians 13 (often used at weddings) will see where I get this idea. (Love is patient, kind, keeps no records of wrongs, etc)
 
Last edited:

Remove ads

Top