Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="D'karr" data-source="post: 1471161" data-attributes="member: 336">You know, that is a funny way to look at things.&nbsp; Specially since when I'm the DM, nothing is official for the campaign unless I say it is.&nbsp; If it doesn't affect your game (you've already said that your players are not like that) then what is the problem?&nbsp; How does this affect YOUR game.&nbsp;I can't be making your point since in Official D&amp;D paladins, sorcerers, monks, etc. already exist.&nbsp; So in your opinion the magazine that provides 100% Official content should not provide content for people that use those classes because it is not &quot;DarkSun.&quot;&nbsp;BTW, since your solution would have been to keep the article as Noonan supposedly wrote it and add the &quot;options&quot;, what prevents you now from taking those &quot;options&quot; that don't fit your vision of DarkSun out?&nbsp;A discerning DM that wants to preserve the &quot;Official&quot; DarkSun can simply remove those things that don't fit.&nbsp; Just like Noonan said he did for his homebrew campaign.&nbsp; Or they can go and convince players to go back to 2e AD&amp;D.&nbsp;Forgive me for not being able to drown in this glass of water.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="D'karr, post: 1471161, member: 336"] You know, that is a funny way to look at things. Specially since when I'm the DM, nothing is official for the campaign unless I say it is. If it doesn't affect your game (you've already said that your players are not like that) then what is the problem? How does this affect YOUR game. I can't be making your point since in Official D&D paladins, sorcerers, monks, etc. already exist. So in your opinion the magazine that provides 100% Official content should not provide content for people that use those classes because it is not "DarkSun." BTW, since your solution would have been to keep the article as Noonan supposedly wrote it and add the "options", what prevents you now from taking those "options" that don't fit your vision of DarkSun out? A discerning DM that wants to preserve the "Official" DarkSun can simply remove those things that don't fit. Just like Noonan said he did for his homebrew campaign. Or they can go and convince players to go back to 2e AD&D. Forgive me for not being able to drown in this glass of water. [/QUOTE]

Verification