Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Enkhidu" data-source="post: 3914335" data-attributes="member: 351">I think the open call was a great idea - modeling one of the most successful WotC ventures in the last 7 years (the setting search that produced Eberron) is a shoo-in for success. And really I've got no gripe with the initial judging. While I wouldn't have necessarily made the same choices, a contest like this requires some form of arbitrary decision making, and the gut feelings of three people who have made a living out of doing this is as good as any.My only "gripe" is that most of us will never see the threads associated with our rejected items. It's only through seeing considered criticism that someone like me might be able to see what about my entry wasn't up to snuff so that I could improve. More than anything, I miss the chance to see what three successful RPG authors said about my stuff. Even if it were brutal, it would at least be something.</blockquote>