Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Sejs" data-source="post: 950666" data-attributes="member: 4910">Three points:1)2) Yes.&nbsp; I read every single word on your commandments post.&nbsp;&nbsp; Several times over.&nbsp; I was looking right at it while I typed up my post.&nbsp; Drop the 'did you even read the...' thing.&nbsp; Yeah, we did.&nbsp; We're also not psychic, so if there's inflection or inferance in your post we will not be able to pick up on them.&nbsp; Text sucks that way.&nbsp; You need to say -exactly- what you mean to get across.Example:The law 'Don't strike a priestess for any reason' is not inherrantly corrupt.&nbsp; It protects female clergy of any god equally.&nbsp; Just because the clerics of Lloth hide behind it doesn't invalidate the law.&nbsp; That is part of the difficulty I'm having with the commandment, you see.3)&nbsp; Looks like my Irreconsilable Difference Radar is going off.&nbsp; We're not going to get anywhere volleying back and forth at one another.&nbsp; I think you're too strict on paladins, you think I'm too lax.. neither of us are going to change our oppinions on this matter.&nbsp; Been there, done this all before, bought the tshirt.So, in answer to your original question - no, I think Paladin should remain a core class.&nbsp; If, in your game, or anyone's game, if they want to PrC up paladins instead, go nuts. That's their option.&nbsp; But I do not think that should be the core way it works.&nbsp; Maybe include it as an optional rule in the Modifying Classes section of the DMG as a sidebar or something.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Sejs, post: 950666, member: 4910"] Three points: 1) 2) Yes. I read every single word on your commandments post. Several times over. I was looking right at it while I typed up my post. Drop the 'did you even read the...' thing. Yeah, we did. We're also not psychic, so if there's inflection or inferance in your post we will not be able to pick up on them. Text sucks that way. You need to say -exactly- what you mean to get across. Example: The law 'Don't strike a priestess for any reason' is not inherrantly corrupt. It protects female clergy of any god equally. Just because the clerics of Lloth hide behind it doesn't invalidate the law. That is part of the difficulty I'm having with the commandment, you see. 3) Looks like my Irreconsilable Difference Radar is going off. We're not going to get anywhere volleying back and forth at one another. I think you're too strict on paladins, you think I'm too lax.. neither of us are going to change our oppinions on this matter. Been there, done this all before, bought the tshirt. So, in answer to your original question - no, I think Paladin should remain a core class. If, in your game, or anyone's game, if they want to PrC up paladins instead, go nuts. That's their option. But I do not think that should be the core way it works. Maybe include it as an optional rule in the Modifying Classes section of the DMG as a sidebar or something. [/QUOTE]

Verification