Menu
News
All News
Dungeons & Dragons
Level Up: Advanced 5th Edition
Pathfinder
Starfinder
Warhammer
2d20 System
Year Zero Engine
Industry News
Reviews
Dragon Reflections
Columns
Weekly Digests
Weekly News Digest
Freebies, Sales & Bundles
RPG Print News
RPG Crowdfunding News
Game Content
ENterplanetary DimENsions
Mythological Figures
Opinion
Worlds of Design
Peregrine's Next
RPG Evolution
Other Columns
From the Freelancing Frontline
Monster ENcyclopedia
WotC/TSR Alumni Look Back
4 Hours w/RSD (Ryan Dancey)
The Road to 3E (Jonathan Tweet)
Greenwood's Realms (Ed Greenwood)
Drawmij's TSR (Jim Ward)
Community
Forums & Topics
Forum List
Latest Posts
Forum list
*Dungeons & Dragons
Level Up: Advanced 5th Edition
D&D Older Editions
*TTRPGs General
*Pathfinder & Starfinder
EN Publishing
*Geek Talk & Media
Search forums
Chat/Discord
Resources
Wiki
Pages
Latest activity
Media
New media
New comments
Search media
Downloads
Latest reviews
Search resources
EN Publishing
Store
EN5ider
Adventures in ZEITGEIST
Awfully Cheerful Engine
What's OLD is NEW
Judge Dredd & The Worlds Of 2000AD
War of the Burning Sky
Level Up: Advanced 5E
Events & Releases
Upcoming Events
Private Events
Featured Events
Socials!
Twitch
YouTube
Facebook (EN Publishing)
Facebook (EN World)
Twitter
Instagram
TikTok
Podcast
Features
Top 5 RPGs Compiled Charts 2004-Present
Adventure Game Industry Market Research Summary (RPGs) V1.0
Ryan Dancey: Acquiring TSR
Q&A With Gary Gygax
D&D Rules FAQs
TSR, WotC, & Paizo: A Comparative History
D&D Pronunciation Guide
Million Dollar TTRPG Kickstarters
Tabletop RPG Podcast Hall of Fame
Eric Noah's Unofficial D&D 3rd Edition News
D&D in the Mainstream
D&D & RPG History
About Morrus
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Search
Search titles only
By:
Forums & Topics
Forum List
Latest Posts
Forum list
*Dungeons & Dragons
Level Up: Advanced 5th Edition
D&D Older Editions
*TTRPGs General
*Pathfinder & Starfinder
EN Publishing
*Geek Talk & Media
Search forums
Chat/Discord
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Community
General Tabletop Discussion
*Pathfinder & Starfinder
Pathfinder 2e: is it RAW or RAI to always take 10 minutes and heal between encounters?
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="!DWolf" data-source="post: 8412727" data-attributes="member: 7026314"><p>Warning: Three thousand word, barely coherent rant incoming.</p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p>First: check out this chart of an AP modules breakdown of monsters by level (specifically Abomination Vaults part 2: Hands of the Devil).</p><p></p><table style='width: 100%'><tr><th>LEVEL</th><th>NUMBER</th><th>PERCENT</th><th>SUM</th></tr><tr><td>-4</td><td>7</td><td>8%</td><td>8%</td></tr><tr><td>-3</td><td>14</td><td>16%</td><td>24%</td></tr><tr><td>-2</td><td>16</td><td>18%</td><td>42%</td></tr><tr><td>-1</td><td>11</td><td>12%</td><td>54%</td></tr><tr><td>0</td><td>17</td><td>19%</td><td>73%</td></tr><tr><td>+1</td><td>7</td><td>8%</td><td>81%</td></tr><tr><td>+2</td><td>14</td><td>16%</td><td>97%</td></tr><tr><td>+3</td><td>3</td><td>3%</td><td>100%</td></tr></table><p></p><p>As you can see only 27% of monsters in this module are a higher level than the players (and this is deceptive because some higher level monsters will try to talk or say go away instead of fighting).</p><p></p><p>Second: you are missing that tactics and strategy will mitigate a huge amount of damage. Let's give an example (from The Slithering):</p><p></p><p>The party is level 6 and consists of:</p><ul> <li data-xf-list-type="ul">DK: A greatsword wielding magus in heavy armor</li> <li data-xf-list-type="ul">LA: A fighter with a guisarme and heavy armor</li> <li data-xf-list-type="ul">AR: A flurry ranger</li> <li data-xf-list-type="ul">HE: A fire elemental sorcerer specialized in blasting</li> </ul><p>They are currently at the entrance of a jungle temple in which they suspect an evil cult has taken over:</p><p></p><p>“This courtyard is circular with a 15' radius. It has an imposing wooden double door at the western end. Each side of the double door bears an enormous carving of a six-fingered hand with long, curved talons. Mosaics on the walls show a horrifying humanoid with saurian and simian features, long sharp horns, and six-fingered clawed hands devouring a variety of creatures. Narrow alcoves to the north and south lead to smaller doors, and the north door is slightly ajar.”</p><p></p><p>[spoiler=SCENARIO 1]</p><p></p><p>The characters walk forward to investigate... and trigger a trap! There is a loud clank and six concealed metal talons in the wall swing out, striking everyone in the room:</p><p>→ DK (18+22) gets crit for 6 points</p><p>→ LA (6+22) gets hit for 12 points</p><p>→ AR (2+22 hits for 3, 5+22 hits for 4, 8+22 hits for 6) for a total of 13 points.</p><p>→ HE (9+22) gets crit for 20 points.</p><p></p><p>Ouch. Everyone hears noises coming from the north. The trap is audibly reseting with a series of clunks and whirs from the wall. The PCs have a single minute to react. What do they do?</p><p></p><p>HE is going to heal, LA is going to rush to the north door and kick it open, AR is going to be on overwatch, and DK is going to follow LA.</p><p></p><p>HE: Casts a three action heal (level 2) and heals everyone for 12 damage.</p><p></p><p>LA: Kicks open the door and combat is initiated as there are two dinosaurs, each 5 foot tall and perched on birdlike legs that end in massive sickle like talons, immediately behind the door. Behind them is a dinosaur-like humanoid wielding a long spear and covered in what looks like trophies from many animals... and people.</p><p></p><p><strong>INITIATIVE</strong></p><p></p><p>DK 29</p><p>AR 28</p><p>AH 21</p><p>HE 20</p><p>LA 16</p><p>D1 15</p><p>D2 14</p><p></p><p><strong>ROUND 1</strong></p><p></p><p>DK: strides into the room and spellstrikes (Produce Flame) the first dinosaur.</p><p>→ AH: Attack of Opportunity on the spellstrike (36 crits) for 34 damage and the spellstrike is disrupted.</p><p></p><p>AR the line of fire on the humanoid dinosaur (the only opponent he can see) is partly blocked by LA and DK. He declares AH as his prey and fires three shots (17, 14, 20) and misses every shot.</p><p></p><p>AH Is going to start by casting fear (3rd) at LA and DK (the only two within range and that it can see).</p><p>→ DK: fails his will save (18) and is frightened 2</p><p>→ LA: fails his will save (21) but is only frightened 1 (thanks to Bravery) AH then attacks DK with using its long spear (Nat 20. crits) for 36 damage.</p><p></p><p>HE: Is going to stride so he can see into the room. Then he uses a two action heal (level 3) on DK, restoring 33 damage.</p><p></p><p>LA: Is going to use knockdown on D1 (29 hits for 9 damage, 17 fails to knockdown). He then strikes again (23 hits) for 14 damage. He is no longer frightened.</p><p></p><p>D1: Attacks DK 3 times. Jaws (14 misses) then both claws (19+7 hits and nat 20 crits) for a total of 14 damage, DK is also bleeding.</p><p></p><p>D2: Attacks DK 3 times. Jaws (30 hits) then both claws (25 hits and 20 hits). DK takes a total of 27 damage. He is koed, falls prone, and drops his sword.</p><p></p><p><strong>ROUND 2</strong></p><p></p><p>AR: Is going to shoot four times at AH (4+15, 17+12, Nat 1, 14+9) hits once for 8 damage.</p><p></p><p>AH: Steps up to DK (who is still frightened 2) and casts deathknell (13 Fails). DK dies. AH is buffed. HE: Is going to three action cast a scorching ray (level 3) against the two dinosaurs and AH. D1 6+12 misses, D2 10+12 hits for 20 damage, 17+12 hits for 15 damage (it resists fire).</p><p></p><p>LA: Is going to attack D1 (36 crits) for 32 damage, which drops it. He is going to attack twice (27 hits for 20 damage, 24 hits for 14 damage) which is enough to drop it as well.</p><p></p><p><strong>ROUND 3</strong> </p><p></p><p>AR: Is going to shoot four times at AH (31, 20, 17, 14) hits once for 8 damage.</p><p></p><p>AH: Is going to strike LA three times (34 crits for 42 damage; 31 hits for 18 damage; 25 hits for 21 damage). That's 81 damage total.</p><p></p><p>HE: Is going to heal LA (2 actions, 3 rd level) for 35 points of damage.</p><p></p><p>LA: Is going to respond in kind: (Nat 1, 19, 17) and misses every attack.</p><p></p><p><strong>ROUND 4</strong> </p><p></p><p>AR: Shoots (34, 26, 17, Nat 20). He hits once and crits once for 22 damage.</p><p></p><p>AH: Is going to strike LA three times (33 hit, 24 hit, 13) for 20 and 23 damage. This drops LA. He falls prone and drops his lance.</p><p></p><p>HE: Is going to 2 action heal (3rd level) LA for 39 points of damage.</p><p></p><p><strong>ROUND 5</strong> </p><p></p><p>AR: Shoots (29, 20, 11, 21). He hits once for 7 damage.</p><p></p><p>LA: Is going to stand up.</p><p>→ AH: attack of opportunity (Nat 20, crits) for deals 46 damage. LA is dying 3.</p><p></p><p>AH: Steps up. Uses deathknell (7+10). LA Dies. AH is buffed.</p><p></p><p>HE: Realizes the fight is lost. Yells run and uses three actions to move away.</p><p></p><p><strong>ROUND 6</strong></p><p></p><p>AR: Uses three actions to move away. Fight changes to chase through the jungle.</p><p></p><p>[/spoiler] [spoiler=SCENARIO 2] Instead of walking into the room, they set up positions by the door while the AR stealthy searches the room for traps, which he spots the trap with a 28. AR then creeps around to get a peak through the door (33 stealth) and gets a look at the two dinosaurs and the fiend training. He designates the fiend as his prey then recalls knowledge (25, 26, then fails with a 22) and learns that it is a type of Fiend known as an ahvothian and that is weak to cold and resistant to fire. He sneaks back and informs the others and they make a plan. DK is going to use invisibility to hide on one side of the door, AL is going to hide on the other. Ranger is going to set a trap in front of the door, place bait just past the trap, and then make a sound to lure the creatures out. Everyone gets into position (36 group stealth!). The trap is set and the ranger makes a dying animal sound.</p><p></p><p><strong>INITIATIVE</strong></p><p>AR 32</p><p>DK 30</p><p>LA 28</p><p>AH 21</p><p>D1 27</p><p>D2 14</p><p>HE 14</p><p></p><p><strong>ROUND 1</strong></p><p></p><p>AR delays</p><p></p><p>DK delays</p><p></p><p>LA delays</p><p></p><p>AH delays</p><p></p><p>D1 goes to check out the noise. It goes to the door, opens it, sees the bait and steps through the doorway and onto the trap (29 vs the trap) but it is unaffected. It has no actions left to look around.</p><p></p><p>LA reenters initiative. He strikes (35 crits for 38 damage). He strikes again (Nat 20 for 42 damage) and demolishes it. He attempts to hide again (16 fails).</p><p></p><p>AH reenters initiative. He strides once to get into the room through the doorway.</p><p>→ LA gets an opportunity attack as he leaves the doorway (27 hits for only 11 damage).</p><p></p><p>AH attacks LA twice (28 hits for 14 damage, and 31 hits for 16 damage) striking for 30 total damage.</p><p></p><p>DK reenters initiative. He spellstrikes with ray of frost (32 hits for 21 slashing and 25 cold) for a total of 46 (AH has taken 57 damage total). He then uses arcane cascade stance (cold).</p><p></p><p>AR reenters initiative. He shoots 4 times (26 hits for 12 damage, 23 misses, 20 miss, 26 hits for 12 damage). That’s a total of 24 damage (AH has taken 81 damage total).</p><p></p><p>D2 Strides up to DK (can’t quite get into a flank but it will be able to with darting attack).</p><p>→ DK takes an attack of opportunity (32 crits for 52 damage) killing it in one blow.</p><p></p><p>HE casts ray of frost at AH (18 misses).</p><p></p><p><strong>ROUND 2</strong></p><p></p><p>LA is going use Knockdown on AH (21 misses). Then strikes (Nat 20) and does 30 damage (AH has taken 111 damage total).</p><p></p><p>AH is going to step out of the flank, then attack DK twice (30 hits, 21 misses) for 18 damage.</p><p></p><p>DK gains 3 temp hp. DK is going to cast shield, thunderous strike (17+15 hits for 28 of fort save. Deals 7 slashing, 2 sonic, 11 cold) then strike (7+10 misses). For a total of 20 damage (AH has taken 131 damage total).</p><p></p><p>AR shoots 4 times (20 miss, 17 miss, 20 miss, 25 hits for 8 damage, 19 miss) for a total of 8 damage. AH has taken (139 damage total).</p><p></p><p>HE uses electric arc (15+12 saves) zapping it for 6 damage (145 damage total).</p><p></p><p><strong>ROUND 3</strong></p><p></p><p>LA is going to step and use knockdown (Nat 20 for 30 damage). And the fight is over as AH goes down. [/spoiler]</p><p></p><p>So comparing these two scenarios, different tactics turned a partial TPK into a fairly cost less victory (DK uses an invisibility spell, DK took 18 points of damage, LA took 30 points of damage). PF2e is very much a game that relies on exploration mode to function and this is what I love about PF2e and why I think it works for me. The rules create opportunities for meaningful decisions (that is decisions where there are consequences) outside of combat. <strong>However</strong>, any game in which the players are allowed to make meaningful decisions allows the possibility of the wrong decisions being made. We see that in the example I posted above.</p><p></p><p>A major problem I see with people on this board trying to run the game is that they/their players don’t want out of combat decisions to affect combat difficult (that is they are very Combat as Sport) and so they don’t let it – every fight becomes a kick in the door and fight whats in the room then reset for the next room. But that makes the game <strong>much</strong> deadlier and it invalidates a lot of the features of the game system. Essentially the game is seeing the players repeatedly make the wrong decisions (kicking in doors without thought) and punishing them for it.</p><p></p><p>This brings me to immersion. If there was a 50% chance that kicking in a door would lead to your death and a 1% chance that acting smart would lead to your death what would you do? Immersion, IMHO, is placing yourself in the shoes of your character and acting like they would given the information that they know. The PF2e world is dangerous, kicking in doors and faffing around will quickly get you killed. Thus, out of combat decision making becomes very important. For example: a party is exploring an orc mine, they have taken the entrance and left their retainers to defend it. They then went deeper in and encountered a patrol of orc guards. Damage was inflicted on both sides, but the orcs retreated, taking a single loss. Two of the PCs are wounded. Now the PCs have a tough choice since they have to balance recovery with what the orcs might do. For example, they could:</p><p>A) Heal up without using resources</p><p>B) Heal up using resources (two PCs would still be wounded) then used the time saved to do something else.</p><p>C) Fortify the room they are in</p><p>D) Pursue the orcs</p><p>F) Retreat to a safe place and then heal up</p><p>E) Split up to do multiple things</p><p>G) Call their retainers up to this room</p><p>H) Something not on this list</p><p></p><p>Let's say they choose to do A and recover some of their missing HP after a ten minute turn with treat wounds (also removes the wounded condition). Then they hear orcish drums beating further in the dungeon... and they are rapidly getting closer. They have a minute to react, what do they do?</p><p>A) Heal the remaining HP, with resources and try to fight the orcs</p><p>B) Retreat to a reinforced position</p><p>C) Desperately attempt to fortify the room</p><p>D) Get into a tactically advantageous position to try and hold of the orc vanguard</p><p>E) Hide and let the orcs pass them</p><p>F) Sit there and wait for the orcs to attack them</p><p>G) Go out and attack the orcs</p><p>H) Something not on this list</p><p></p><p>Lets say they choose D and fight a couple rounds at the door to the room, dropping a couple orcs. Then the front line is shoved out of position and orcs start flooding into the room, the badly hurt PCs then retreat covered by the spells from the wizard. They get back to the previously fortified room where their retainers have been waiting, they have a minute before the orcs catch up. What do they do?</p><p>A) Heal as best they can and use the fortifications to try and hold, sending away their retainers to safety</p><p>B) Heal as best they can, but keep the retainers present to provide additional healing and support, to try and hold longer at risk to the retainers</p><p>C) Convince the retainers to fight the orcs off in order to give them time to heal (or retreat)</p><p>D) Order a retreat to the surface</p><p>E) Order a retreat to the surface leaving a couple of characters as a rear-guard to try and delay the orcs</p><p>F) Something else not on this list</p><p></p><p>Lets say they choose B. After a tense fight, they are forced to retreat out of the dungeon and a chase ensues. They escape but a PC and many retainers are lost. The remaining retainers are quite mad at the PCs and are threatening to leave. What do the PCs do?</p><p></p><p>And the chain continues. Each decision has consequences and the chain of decisions and consequences creates an engaging game. Tension is created because players don't have perfect information about the consequences of the decisions they make: they have to put themselves in the characters shoes and use skill and judgment in making decisions. And if they make the wrong decisions things could go disastrously. This, IMHO, is what creates immersion: imaging yourself in a scenario and thinking, what would I do if I was there and had realistic motivations (like NOT DYING)? What steps would I take? Would the steps I like to take put me in conflict with another characters steps to achieve their motivation?</p><p></p><p>This is of course the Combat as War philosophy as opposed to the Combat as Sport philosophy. And it’s okay to like Combat as Sport (though I personally feel like it turns the experience into an overly complicated board game, I understand that different people like different things). What I am saying is that PF2e is <strong>NOT</strong> Combat as Sport by default (see the above example for instance, or a zillion of my previous posts in various threads). Trying to run it as a hp attrition based series of combats where no decisions are made between them and only the 8th combat in a day has any chance of hurting the PCs will not work simply because of how the system is designed. You could of course change it to try and run as a Combat as Sport game (adding auto-healing between encounters as an example), but why not just run a system that plays that way by default such as 4E?</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="!DWolf, post: 8412727, member: 7026314"] Warning: Three thousand word, barely coherent rant incoming. First: check out this chart of an AP modules breakdown of monsters by level (specifically Abomination Vaults part 2: Hands of the Devil). [TABLE] [TR] [TH]LEVEL[/TH] [TH]NUMBER[/TH] [TH]PERCENT[/TH] [TH]SUM[/TH] [/TR] [TR] [TD]-4[/TD] [TD]7[/TD] [TD]8%[/TD] [TD]8%[/TD] [/TR] [TR] [TD]-3[/TD] [TD]14[/TD] [TD]16%[/TD] [TD]24%[/TD] [/TR] [TR] [TD]-2[/TD] [TD]16[/TD] [TD]18%[/TD] [TD]42%[/TD] [/TR] [TR] [TD]-1[/TD] [TD]11[/TD] [TD]12%[/TD] [TD]54%[/TD] [/TR] [TR] [TD]0[/TD] [TD]17[/TD] [TD]19%[/TD] [TD]73%[/TD] [/TR] [TR] [TD]+1[/TD] [TD]7[/TD] [TD]8%[/TD] [TD]81%[/TD] [/TR] [TR] [TD]+2[/TD] [TD]14[/TD] [TD]16%[/TD] [TD]97%[/TD] [/TR] [TR] [TD]+3[/TD] [TD]3[/TD] [TD]3%[/TD] [TD]100%[/TD] [/TR] [/TABLE] As you can see only 27% of monsters in this module are a higher level than the players (and this is deceptive because some higher level monsters will try to talk or say go away instead of fighting). Second: you are missing that tactics and strategy will mitigate a huge amount of damage. Let's give an example (from The Slithering): The party is level 6 and consists of: [LIST] [*]DK: A greatsword wielding magus in heavy armor [*]LA: A fighter with a guisarme and heavy armor [*]AR: A flurry ranger [*]HE: A fire elemental sorcerer specialized in blasting [/LIST] They are currently at the entrance of a jungle temple in which they suspect an evil cult has taken over: “This courtyard is circular with a 15' radius. It has an imposing wooden double door at the western end. Each side of the double door bears an enormous carving of a six-fingered hand with long, curved talons. Mosaics on the walls show a horrifying humanoid with saurian and simian features, long sharp horns, and six-fingered clawed hands devouring a variety of creatures. Narrow alcoves to the north and south lead to smaller doors, and the north door is slightly ajar.” [spoiler=SCENARIO 1] The characters walk forward to investigate... and trigger a trap! There is a loud clank and six concealed metal talons in the wall swing out, striking everyone in the room: → DK (18+22) gets crit for 6 points → LA (6+22) gets hit for 12 points → AR (2+22 hits for 3, 5+22 hits for 4, 8+22 hits for 6) for a total of 13 points. → HE (9+22) gets crit for 20 points. Ouch. Everyone hears noises coming from the north. The trap is audibly reseting with a series of clunks and whirs from the wall. The PCs have a single minute to react. What do they do? HE is going to heal, LA is going to rush to the north door and kick it open, AR is going to be on overwatch, and DK is going to follow LA. HE: Casts a three action heal (level 2) and heals everyone for 12 damage. LA: Kicks open the door and combat is initiated as there are two dinosaurs, each 5 foot tall and perched on birdlike legs that end in massive sickle like talons, immediately behind the door. Behind them is a dinosaur-like humanoid wielding a long spear and covered in what looks like trophies from many animals... and people. [B]INITIATIVE[/B] DK 29 AR 28 AH 21 HE 20 LA 16 D1 15 D2 14 [B]ROUND 1[/B] DK: strides into the room and spellstrikes (Produce Flame) the first dinosaur. → AH: Attack of Opportunity on the spellstrike (36 crits) for 34 damage and the spellstrike is disrupted. AR the line of fire on the humanoid dinosaur (the only opponent he can see) is partly blocked by LA and DK. He declares AH as his prey and fires three shots (17, 14, 20) and misses every shot. AH Is going to start by casting fear (3rd) at LA and DK (the only two within range and that it can see). → DK: fails his will save (18) and is frightened 2 → LA: fails his will save (21) but is only frightened 1 (thanks to Bravery) AH then attacks DK with using its long spear (Nat 20. crits) for 36 damage. HE: Is going to stride so he can see into the room. Then he uses a two action heal (level 3) on DK, restoring 33 damage. LA: Is going to use knockdown on D1 (29 hits for 9 damage, 17 fails to knockdown). He then strikes again (23 hits) for 14 damage. He is no longer frightened. D1: Attacks DK 3 times. Jaws (14 misses) then both claws (19+7 hits and nat 20 crits) for a total of 14 damage, DK is also bleeding. D2: Attacks DK 3 times. Jaws (30 hits) then both claws (25 hits and 20 hits). DK takes a total of 27 damage. He is koed, falls prone, and drops his sword. [B]ROUND 2[/B] AR: Is going to shoot four times at AH (4+15, 17+12, Nat 1, 14+9) hits once for 8 damage. AH: Steps up to DK (who is still frightened 2) and casts deathknell (13 Fails). DK dies. AH is buffed. HE: Is going to three action cast a scorching ray (level 3) against the two dinosaurs and AH. D1 6+12 misses, D2 10+12 hits for 20 damage, 17+12 hits for 15 damage (it resists fire). LA: Is going to attack D1 (36 crits) for 32 damage, which drops it. He is going to attack twice (27 hits for 20 damage, 24 hits for 14 damage) which is enough to drop it as well. [B]ROUND 3[/B] AR: Is going to shoot four times at AH (31, 20, 17, 14) hits once for 8 damage. AH: Is going to strike LA three times (34 crits for 42 damage; 31 hits for 18 damage; 25 hits for 21 damage). That's 81 damage total. HE: Is going to heal LA (2 actions, 3 rd level) for 35 points of damage. LA: Is going to respond in kind: (Nat 1, 19, 17) and misses every attack. [B]ROUND 4[/B] AR: Shoots (34, 26, 17, Nat 20). He hits once and crits once for 22 damage. AH: Is going to strike LA three times (33 hit, 24 hit, 13) for 20 and 23 damage. This drops LA. He falls prone and drops his lance. HE: Is going to 2 action heal (3rd level) LA for 39 points of damage. [B]ROUND 5[/B] AR: Shoots (29, 20, 11, 21). He hits once for 7 damage. LA: Is going to stand up. → AH: attack of opportunity (Nat 20, crits) for deals 46 damage. LA is dying 3. AH: Steps up. Uses deathknell (7+10). LA Dies. AH is buffed. HE: Realizes the fight is lost. Yells run and uses three actions to move away. [B]ROUND 6[/B] AR: Uses three actions to move away. Fight changes to chase through the jungle. [/spoiler] [spoiler=SCENARIO 2] Instead of walking into the room, they set up positions by the door while the AR stealthy searches the room for traps, which he spots the trap with a 28. AR then creeps around to get a peak through the door (33 stealth) and gets a look at the two dinosaurs and the fiend training. He designates the fiend as his prey then recalls knowledge (25, 26, then fails with a 22) and learns that it is a type of Fiend known as an ahvothian and that is weak to cold and resistant to fire. He sneaks back and informs the others and they make a plan. DK is going to use invisibility to hide on one side of the door, AL is going to hide on the other. Ranger is going to set a trap in front of the door, place bait just past the trap, and then make a sound to lure the creatures out. Everyone gets into position (36 group stealth!). The trap is set and the ranger makes a dying animal sound. [B]INITIATIVE[/B] AR 32 DK 30 LA 28 AH 21 D1 27 D2 14 HE 14 [B]ROUND 1[/B] AR delays DK delays LA delays AH delays D1 goes to check out the noise. It goes to the door, opens it, sees the bait and steps through the doorway and onto the trap (29 vs the trap) but it is unaffected. It has no actions left to look around. LA reenters initiative. He strikes (35 crits for 38 damage). He strikes again (Nat 20 for 42 damage) and demolishes it. He attempts to hide again (16 fails). AH reenters initiative. He strides once to get into the room through the doorway. → LA gets an opportunity attack as he leaves the doorway (27 hits for only 11 damage). AH attacks LA twice (28 hits for 14 damage, and 31 hits for 16 damage) striking for 30 total damage. DK reenters initiative. He spellstrikes with ray of frost (32 hits for 21 slashing and 25 cold) for a total of 46 (AH has taken 57 damage total). He then uses arcane cascade stance (cold). AR reenters initiative. He shoots 4 times (26 hits for 12 damage, 23 misses, 20 miss, 26 hits for 12 damage). That’s a total of 24 damage (AH has taken 81 damage total). D2 Strides up to DK (can’t quite get into a flank but it will be able to with darting attack). → DK takes an attack of opportunity (32 crits for 52 damage) killing it in one blow. HE casts ray of frost at AH (18 misses). [B]ROUND 2[/B] LA is going use Knockdown on AH (21 misses). Then strikes (Nat 20) and does 30 damage (AH has taken 111 damage total). AH is going to step out of the flank, then attack DK twice (30 hits, 21 misses) for 18 damage. DK gains 3 temp hp. DK is going to cast shield, thunderous strike (17+15 hits for 28 of fort save. Deals 7 slashing, 2 sonic, 11 cold) then strike (7+10 misses). For a total of 20 damage (AH has taken 131 damage total). AR shoots 4 times (20 miss, 17 miss, 20 miss, 25 hits for 8 damage, 19 miss) for a total of 8 damage. AH has taken (139 damage total). HE uses electric arc (15+12 saves) zapping it for 6 damage (145 damage total). [B]ROUND 3[/B] LA is going to step and use knockdown (Nat 20 for 30 damage). And the fight is over as AH goes down. [/spoiler] So comparing these two scenarios, different tactics turned a partial TPK into a fairly cost less victory (DK uses an invisibility spell, DK took 18 points of damage, LA took 30 points of damage). PF2e is very much a game that relies on exploration mode to function and this is what I love about PF2e and why I think it works for me. The rules create opportunities for meaningful decisions (that is decisions where there are consequences) outside of combat. [B]However[/B], any game in which the players are allowed to make meaningful decisions allows the possibility of the wrong decisions being made. We see that in the example I posted above. A major problem I see with people on this board trying to run the game is that they/their players don’t want out of combat decisions to affect combat difficult (that is they are very Combat as Sport) and so they don’t let it – every fight becomes a kick in the door and fight whats in the room then reset for the next room. But that makes the game [B]much[/B] deadlier and it invalidates a lot of the features of the game system. Essentially the game is seeing the players repeatedly make the wrong decisions (kicking in doors without thought) and punishing them for it. This brings me to immersion. If there was a 50% chance that kicking in a door would lead to your death and a 1% chance that acting smart would lead to your death what would you do? Immersion, IMHO, is placing yourself in the shoes of your character and acting like they would given the information that they know. The PF2e world is dangerous, kicking in doors and faffing around will quickly get you killed. Thus, out of combat decision making becomes very important. For example: a party is exploring an orc mine, they have taken the entrance and left their retainers to defend it. They then went deeper in and encountered a patrol of orc guards. Damage was inflicted on both sides, but the orcs retreated, taking a single loss. Two of the PCs are wounded. Now the PCs have a tough choice since they have to balance recovery with what the orcs might do. For example, they could: A) Heal up without using resources B) Heal up using resources (two PCs would still be wounded) then used the time saved to do something else. C) Fortify the room they are in D) Pursue the orcs F) Retreat to a safe place and then heal up E) Split up to do multiple things G) Call their retainers up to this room H) Something not on this list Let's say they choose to do A and recover some of their missing HP after a ten minute turn with treat wounds (also removes the wounded condition). Then they hear orcish drums beating further in the dungeon... and they are rapidly getting closer. They have a minute to react, what do they do? A) Heal the remaining HP, with resources and try to fight the orcs B) Retreat to a reinforced position C) Desperately attempt to fortify the room D) Get into a tactically advantageous position to try and hold of the orc vanguard E) Hide and let the orcs pass them F) Sit there and wait for the orcs to attack them G) Go out and attack the orcs H) Something not on this list Lets say they choose D and fight a couple rounds at the door to the room, dropping a couple orcs. Then the front line is shoved out of position and orcs start flooding into the room, the badly hurt PCs then retreat covered by the spells from the wizard. They get back to the previously fortified room where their retainers have been waiting, they have a minute before the orcs catch up. What do they do? A) Heal as best they can and use the fortifications to try and hold, sending away their retainers to safety B) Heal as best they can, but keep the retainers present to provide additional healing and support, to try and hold longer at risk to the retainers C) Convince the retainers to fight the orcs off in order to give them time to heal (or retreat) D) Order a retreat to the surface E) Order a retreat to the surface leaving a couple of characters as a rear-guard to try and delay the orcs F) Something else not on this list Lets say they choose B. After a tense fight, they are forced to retreat out of the dungeon and a chase ensues. They escape but a PC and many retainers are lost. The remaining retainers are quite mad at the PCs and are threatening to leave. What do the PCs do? And the chain continues. Each decision has consequences and the chain of decisions and consequences creates an engaging game. Tension is created because players don't have perfect information about the consequences of the decisions they make: they have to put themselves in the characters shoes and use skill and judgment in making decisions. And if they make the wrong decisions things could go disastrously. This, IMHO, is what creates immersion: imaging yourself in a scenario and thinking, what would I do if I was there and had realistic motivations (like NOT DYING)? What steps would I take? Would the steps I like to take put me in conflict with another characters steps to achieve their motivation? This is of course the Combat as War philosophy as opposed to the Combat as Sport philosophy. And it’s okay to like Combat as Sport (though I personally feel like it turns the experience into an overly complicated board game, I understand that different people like different things). What I am saying is that PF2e is [B]NOT[/B] Combat as Sport by default (see the above example for instance, or a zillion of my previous posts in various threads). Trying to run it as a hp attrition based series of combats where no decisions are made between them and only the 8th combat in a day has any chance of hurting the PCs will not work simply because of how the system is designed. You could of course change it to try and run as a Combat as Sport game (adding auto-healing between encounters as an example), but why not just run a system that plays that way by default such as 4E? [/QUOTE]
Insert quotes…
Verification
Post reply
Community
General Tabletop Discussion
*Pathfinder & Starfinder
Pathfinder 2e: is it RAW or RAI to always take 10 minutes and heal between encounters?
Top