Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="der_kluge" data-source="post: 3760105" data-attributes="member: 945">I picked up a bunch of Judge's Guild stuff on eBay recently.You can't get much more old school than that.Here's some of the wonkiness that I've read lately:One dungeon had orcs in one room, and ghouls just two rooms over.&nbsp; Apparently ghouls in 1st edition don't have legs, because I'm pretty certain that if that were a real situation, the ghouls would have walked over and killed all the orcs.Down one level, we find two humans working a &quot;fully equipped&quot; smithy - in a basement. With no ventilation.&nbsp; Apparently humans in that setting are immune to black lung disease, and have no odor whatsoever, because I'm pretty sure the ghouls should have killed them, too.In a different dungeon (same product), we find a hallway leading the room containing the BBEG. There is 1 (one) hallway and only one hallway leading into this. It had a 10' weight-sensitive trap. One a 1 on a 1d6, it shoots spears out from the walls. On a 2 on a 1d6, it shoots out streams of acid.&nbsp; There's no mention of how the BBEG gets into his room, or who his servants get in and out of the room.&nbsp; Maybe they walk on the walls, I guess.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="der_kluge, post: 3760105, member: 945"] I picked up a bunch of Judge's Guild stuff on eBay recently. You can't get much more old school than that. Here's some of the wonkiness that I've read lately: One dungeon had orcs in one room, and ghouls just two rooms over. Apparently ghouls in 1st edition don't have legs, because I'm pretty certain that if that were a real situation, the ghouls would have walked over and killed all the orcs. Down one level, we find two humans working a "fully equipped" smithy - in a basement. With no ventilation. Apparently humans in that setting are immune to black lung disease, and have no odor whatsoever, because I'm pretty sure the ghouls should have killed them, too. In a different dungeon (same product), we find a hallway leading the room containing the BBEG. There is 1 (one) hallway and only one hallway leading into this. It had a 10' weight-sensitive trap. One a 1 on a 1d6, it shoots spears out from the walls. On a 2 on a 1d6, it shoots out streams of acid. There's no mention of how the BBEG gets into his room, or who his servants get in and out of the room. Maybe they walk on the walls, I guess. [/QUOTE]

Verification