Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Graf" data-source="post: 4113319" data-attributes="member: 3087">I like the idea. I agree that -some- discussion of "how will this work" instead of "It won't work" or "I'm gonna house rule this cause it's obviously not going to work" would be good.I mean... you'd still get "for" and "against" concepts and ideas and there'd need to be moderation, satisfy Eric's grandmother and so forth.I know that some number of people I know (most of whom are lurkers) on the boards are getting in a mind to start thinking about prepping/testing/running/brainstorming.We can just do it by email but in the past EnWorld has offered a rich environment for cross pollination. It would be nice to see that continue.If a forum is too much work (and I think it might be a lot of work for whoever sets it up) Would the moderators "bless" it idea of a "uniform" post head, which would clearly state what was appropriate and inappropriate (i.e. not stifle debate per se, but encourage people who want to post "and this is why I don't like 4e" to make a separate thread linking to it instead of dumping directly into the thread).For example:Thread Title (in 4e forum): [Constructive Criticism only] My new 4e campaign idea: Return to the FeywildAnd lead with some piece of set block text:The wording of the block text, obviously, would need to be a bit better.I'm not an overwhelming supporter of 4e per se (I like and play most every rpg at this point in my life), but I do think that some of the dumping is getting a bit toxic. There's nothing wrong with being exited about 4e and the whole "roast people who like it! get 'em get 'em!" thing was stale the second it started.</blockquote>

Verification