Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="KarinsDad" data-source="post: 5134232" data-attributes="member: 2011">Good point. That takes care of the Aura and attack issue as long as one considers the starting square to have the imaginary lines touching. PCs outside of the blocking terrain are also invisible to the phasing creature. No LOE, no LOS.If there wasn't an entire section on &quot;Occupied Squares&quot; and other rules that referred to occupied or unoccupied such as &quot;Pick up an object in your space or in an unoccupied square within reach&quot;, where the only rational meaning is that a creature is in the square, then I would agree with you.As is, the main references to occupied square or unoccupied square refer to squares with creatures in them or not.If you can find ones that explicitly refer to objects, then your POV has some RAW merit.There is a difference between how we want a rule to work and how the rule actually works.And actually, I see no problem with a phasing creature ending its turn in a solid object. As long, as you also pointed out, that the creature cannot attack from there. Good job.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="KarinsDad, post: 5134232, member: 2011"] Good point. That takes care of the Aura and attack issue as long as one considers the starting square to have the imaginary lines touching. PCs outside of the blocking terrain are also invisible to the phasing creature. No LOE, no LOS. If there wasn't an entire section on "Occupied Squares" and other rules that referred to occupied or unoccupied such as "Pick up an object in your space or in an [b]unoccupied square[/b] within reach", where the only rational meaning is that a creature is in the square, then I would agree with you. As is, the main references to occupied square or unoccupied square refer to squares with creatures in them or not. If you can find ones that explicitly refer to objects, then your POV has some RAW merit. There is a difference between how we want a rule to work and how the rule actually works. And actually, I see no problem with a phasing creature ending its turn in a solid object. As long, as you also pointed out, that the creature cannot attack from there. Good job. [/QUOTE]

Verification