Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Bran Blackbyrd" data-source="post: 1714523" data-attributes="member: 1710">Except that it wasn't a book about grunge and punk. Clearly a Hong Kong martial arts movie is a&nbsp; Hong Kong martial arts movie. So now you're saying that a book about the planes and a floating, neutral city/crossroads was about grunge and punk. Interesting. But stupid.Either an assumption or an impressive display of mind-reading When did I make such a claim. You love to make up facts, don't you?You prefer what is essentially the planes, PRE-Planescape and I'm the one resisting change? Heh.And when did I even suggest that that choice be taken away? Quote it. Oops, I never said anything of the sort. This strawman you've created is just wasting space.Same strawman.Try to realize that a one-shot Planescape book wouldn't preclude the existance of books like the Planar Handbook. That no one is suggesting doing away with regular, non-PS planar books, and that the strawman routine is getting tired.Not only did I not suggest that non-PS planar books be done away with, at the moment I don't recall reading that anyone else had either. The way you're ranting you'd think that someone was going to go door to door taking back everyone's copies of the Planar Handbook. What are you so worried about, it's already been published?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Bran Blackbyrd, post: 1714523, member: 1710"] Except that it wasn't a book about grunge and punk. Clearly a Hong Kong martial arts movie is a Hong Kong martial arts movie. So now you're saying that a book about the planes and a floating, neutral city/crossroads was about grunge and punk. Interesting. But stupid. Either an assumption or an impressive display of mind-reading When did I make such a claim. You love to make up facts, don't you? You prefer what is essentially the planes, PRE-Planescape and [i]I'm[/i] the one resisting change? Heh. And when did I even suggest that that choice be taken away? Quote it. Oops, I never said anything of the sort. This strawman you've created is just wasting space. Same strawman. Try to realize that a one-shot Planescape book wouldn't preclude the existance of books like the Planar Handbook. That no one is suggesting doing away with regular, non-PS planar books, and that the strawman routine is getting tired. Not only did I not suggest that non-PS planar books be done away with, at the moment I don't recall reading that anyone else had either. The way you're ranting you'd think that someone was going to go door to door taking back everyone's copies of the Planar Handbook. What are you so worried about, it's already been published? [/QUOTE]

Verification