Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.
Rocket your D&D 5E and Level Up: Advanced 5E games into space! Alpha Star Magazine Is Launching... Right Now!

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Goumindong" data-source="post: 4768255" data-attributes="member: 70874">The only concern you should be looking at is whether or not you can afford the extra -2 penalty on skill checks until paragon tier. But you probably won't have enough dex anyway, so its almost a moot point. If you're a fighter, its probably still a good idea even though it costs you a feat.Anyway, the question of "too much AC" almost never happens in my experience. This is both as playing a 1-3rd level fighter, a 6-8th level fighter and DM'ing 9 levels with a Chaladin. AND in the math. I cannot say much except that "High AC and lots of healing surges is something every defender should have" is a lesson learned from my play.The math however, is pretty explicit. Lets assume that you're a 18 str/18 cha level 1 Dragonborn Paladin. Your Divine Challenge hits for 7 damage and you have 20 AC.  Your buddy is an 18 dex rogue with leather armor for 16 AC.Alright, so if an enemy attacks your buddy he has to get an 18 and if he attacks you he has to get a 20. This is a difference of 2/20 or 1/10. So, if we also assume that he does 10 damage average. When he attacks the rogue he trades marginal outgoing DPR of 1 for a marginal incoming DPR of 7. If you are wearing scale instead, the marginal outgoing DPR is .5 and marginal incoming DPR is 7.Now, the question is not really "what is the DPR difference that they see" the question is "what is the ratio at which its rational to stop attacking the paladin and start attacking someone else" because so long as you're within that ratio they're going to attack you and if that is the case then you want the marginal outgoing DPR to be as high as possible. Anyway, hit points aren't created equal. At lower levels you and the monsters are about equal in terms of hit points and DPR. As you go up in level, monsters start getting more high points than you pretty quickly. BUT: You can heal easily and they cannot.The fact that you can heal at lower levels makes your hit points less valuable than the monsters. If you go below zero you can probably be brought back up the next round to 1/4 your hit points +1d6. To top that off, any damage that was done to you in the negative range... its as if that never existed. Its the same way at upper levels but you have more ways to heal and more bonuses added on top of it.So at level one the monsters ask "Is +1 DPR out worth +7 DPR in" and the answer is going to be, almost invariably "no"[iirc you've got to get to something like 1:2 to make it worth it, but getting that exactly is beyond the scope of this question]. But clearly that isn't the case all the time, there have to be extenuating circumstances that make the enemy want to hit someone else other than the Paladin. And the answer is yes, there are, but they are largely going to want to attack anyone other than the Paladin in those situations anyway, so you're not really losing much.The "when" those things happen is when the 7 damage that you will be doing is inconsequential. I.E. if your striker hits for 10 minimum damage and the enemy has 9 hit points the 7 damage largely do not matter, he is going down the next round and he is going down in 1 successful attack, whether or not he takes the extra damage or not.[Also, if the enemy expects to die in a single OA and so would not be likely to get any more actions after the next turn anyway]There are other instances too. Single target encounter powers are a big one. The bigger the average damage the more that the enemy wants to use it on someone else[his marginal outgoing DPR will be going up, usually 2-3 fold]. These can be a big deal. but these are more likely to be burst powers anyway, and as well, you're going to need times when your allies take a beating for you. There is such thing as "defending too well".Anyway, the point is, go with plate, the guy you marked is going to attack you(and maybe others too to try and focus fire)</blockquote>

Verification