Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Wik" data-source="post: 6627071" data-attributes="member: 40177">I'm about to go to bed, so I don't really have too much time to reply.&nbsp;&nbsp; But I felt like I needed to address one point:&nbsp; You were asking for feedback on your ideas.&nbsp; For the record, I'm 98% happy with 5E, and I don't think your ideas are particularly good for my campaign.&nbsp; I feel they'd slow game to a crawl, OR, if you have a plot going on, wouldn't be able to be used, which would be frustrating for players.&nbsp; As an honest point, I have a feeling, from looking at your posts, that 5e might not be 100% to your style.&nbsp; Your houserules add a bunch of complexity to a game that had as a design goal &quot;Make it simpler!&quot;&nbsp; My question, and it's an honest, snark free one, is why play fifth if you just want to add a buttload of granularity?&nbsp; Why not play pathfinder?&nbsp; Or Earthdawn?&nbsp; or 1e?&nbsp; Or 3e?&nbsp; Or 4e?&nbsp; What is it about fifth that you actually like, and why are you using it as a base for your modified game system?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Wik, post: 6627071, member: 40177"] I'm about to go to bed, so I don't really have too much time to reply. But I felt like I needed to address one point: You were asking for feedback on your ideas. For the record, I'm 98% happy with 5E, and I don't think your ideas are particularly good for my campaign. I feel they'd slow game to a crawl, OR, if you have a plot going on, wouldn't be able to be used, which would be frustrating for players. As an honest point, I have a feeling, from looking at your posts, that 5e might not be 100% to your style. Your houserules add a bunch of complexity to a game that had as a design goal "Make it simpler!" My question, and it's an honest, snark free one, is why play fifth if you just want to add a buttload of granularity? Why not play pathfinder? Or Earthdawn? or 1e? Or 3e? Or 4e? What is it about fifth that you actually like, and why are you using it as a base for your modified game system? [/QUOTE]

Verification