Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Crimson Longinus" data-source="post: 9419633" data-attributes="member: 7025508">Yes, but then we should actually be more exact about what that involves.But if the thing the player goal was related to was already established to exist in the setting, isn't that still selecting from GM created options, even though that might be choosing among thousand options rather than two? Does or does not your definition require the player to invent the setting elements related to their goal or does it not? Is it "player-established quest" to explore ancient giant civilization, even if the player did not establish the fact that giants exist in the setting and had an ancient civilization?Sure. With the caveat that the GM has final say regarding what's poosible. But in my decades of playing RPGs, I don't remember this ever being in any other way. RPG rules are never exact with just limited set of options like a computer game; the cool thing about RPGs is that you're not limited in that way.</blockquote>