Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="aco175" data-source="post: 8916251" data-attributes="member: 27385">Is it always the player's choice though.&nbsp; If someone is playing a PC that acts against the rest of the party, is the party in their right to ask that PC to leave and replace them with another PC?&nbsp; Would I be a jerk player if I wanted to play my character to not like others stealing from the party and your Pc was stealing from the party.&nbsp; When both out characters, our choices come into conflict, what happens?&nbsp; There seems to be two angles here, where a player can come to the game with any PC they want and other players want to have a group that works together.&nbsp; If we sat down to play and you someone said, &quot;I'm going to play the cleric, you play the rogue.&quot;&nbsp; Why would I be the jerk when I find out they are not playing that part of the team?&nbsp; There should be ways to play your character the way one wants and still be part of the team in the role you chose.&nbsp; Others said that means casting a few healing words when needed and maybe a raise dead.&nbsp; That likely works fine in 5e.&nbsp; Actively going against that part of being a team maybe makes that player a jerk instead of me.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="aco175, post: 8916251, member: 27385"] Is it always the player's choice though. If someone is playing a PC that acts against the rest of the party, is the party in their right to ask that PC to leave and replace them with another PC? Would I be a jerk player if I wanted to play my character to not like others stealing from the party and your Pc was stealing from the party. When both out characters, our choices come into conflict, what happens? There seems to be two angles here, where a player can come to the game with any PC they want and other players want to have a group that works together. If we sat down to play and you someone said, "I'm going to play the cleric, you play the rogue." Why would I be the jerk when I find out they are not playing that part of the team? There should be ways to play your character the way one wants and still be part of the team in the role you chose. Others said that means casting a few healing words when needed and maybe a raise dead. That likely works fine in 5e. Actively going against that part of being a team maybe makes that player a jerk instead of me. [/QUOTE]

Verification