Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Relique du Madde" data-source="post: 2957583" data-attributes="member: 42169">I'm not really sure why it worked the way it does, but I have some theories..&nbsp;- JAck's &quot;desires&quot; the Black Pearl (it only shows him the direction of the pearl)&nbsp;- Elizabeth &quot;desires&quot; Will/Jack/&quot;Freedom&quot; (Her heart's confused which is why it fluctated often)Now, *MAYBE* it requires two people to use properly for the purpose of finding Davy Jones's Heart.&nbsp; The one person has to hold the compass (thus establishing a base line to what he/she desires) and the second person's own desire adjusts the reading so that it points to an object that can fulfill both desires.. SO....&nbsp; Elizabeth Alone-----------&gt; Jack/Will/Freedom&nbsp; Jack Alone ---------------&gt; The ability to sail the black pearl unchallanged*&nbsp; Jack + Elizabeth ---------&gt; Common Desire:&quot;Freedom from Davy Jones&quot;&nbsp; Now since Jack and Elizabeth both desired freedom from Davy Jones (to some extent) the compass then pointed to the item which can fullfill that desire, Davy Jones's heart.*At this point Davy Jones is the strongest threat to Jacks Ability to sail the Black Pearl.&nbsp; When he looks at the compass it goes wild since *everyone* is a potential threat (&quot;eh, pirate&quot;) or because while over water there is no escape from Davy Jones (since it would point to the source of the threat).</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Relique du Madde, post: 2957583, member: 42169"] I'm not really sure why it worked the way it does, but I have some theories.. - JAck's "desires" the Black Pearl (it only shows him the direction of the pearl) - Elizabeth "desires" Will/Jack/"Freedom" (Her heart's confused which is why it fluctated often) Now, *MAYBE* it requires two people to use properly for the purpose of finding Davy Jones's Heart. The one person has to hold the compass (thus establishing a base line to what he/she desires) and the second person's own desire adjusts the reading so that it points to an object that can fulfill both desires.. SO.... Elizabeth Alone-----------> Jack/Will/Freedom Jack Alone ---------------> The ability to sail the black pearl unchallanged* Jack + Elizabeth ---------> Common Desire:"Freedom from Davy Jones" Now since Jack and Elizabeth both desired freedom from Davy Jones (to some extent) the compass then pointed to the item which can fullfill that desire, Davy Jones's heart. *At this point Davy Jones is the strongest threat to Jacks Ability to sail the Black Pearl. When he looks at the compass it goes wild since *everyone* is a potential threat ("eh, pirate") or because while over water there is no escape from Davy Jones (since it would point to the source of the threat). [/QUOTE]

Verification