Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Mistwell" data-source="post: 1127142" data-attributes="member: 2525">I think this debate is worthwhile.  I have a character with this feat, and we have been using the interpretation that comes out with the lower damage (+8, not +10).  However, I would love to be persuaded that it is the higher number, for obvious reasons.That said, I think it is incredibly silly that two people, on opposite sides of this debate, have both said they KNOW how this feat works.  You don't KNOW how this feat works.  There is a reasonable dispute about how it works, and we have equally semi-official rulings on both sides of the debate according to folks here.  You can offer an opinion as to which you think is the better intepretation.  You can offer evidence that one side of the debate has more support in the D&D gaming community than the other.  You can analyze the debate based on other official answers about related subjects.  But none of that will add up to KNOWING how this feat works.  Because we do not know for sure, as long as people can articulate a reasonable intepretation on both sides of the debate and a final and definitive official answer remains elusive.So can we please back off on the certainty used in the language here, and get back to the debate over which intpretation is the one more supported by the rules and logic?</blockquote>