Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.
Rocket your D&D 5E and Level Up: Advanced 5E games into space! Alpha Star Magazine Is Launching... Right Now!

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="gyor" data-source="post: 7945657" data-attributes="member: 6670153">Read the qoute again, Satyrs also get resist magic just like Yuan Ti Purebloods. I'm not sure how to rate the fact that Satyr's are fey, on one hand that means immune to charm person and dominate person, on the other hand the Channel Divinity of the Oath of the Ancients Paladin is going to be a head ache, and having  Banish cast on the Satyr is a huge head ache until someone in the party can cast Planeshift. Still how many enemies cast Banish? And there does it Banish a Satyr in Theros anyways, is there a Feywild to banish them too? I know their is a Nyx and Underworld but how does that fit into a D&D cosmology. See this has not been dealt with in Ravnica either, but at some point will have to be addressed when translating MtG settings to D&D. D&D spells are designed for the D&D Cosmology, not the MtG cosmology. If I'm on Ravnica and I cast Etherness that has implications for the setting, which is that Ravnica has a Ethereal Plane to go to. Someone casts Banish on my Satyr on Theros, that fey Satyr will go to the Feywild, which means Theros also has a Feywild for them to be sent to. If I cast Banish on a Zombie on Ravnica, that Zombie goes the Ravnica's Shadowfell, which means Ravnica has a Shadowfell. The D&D cosmology is baked into the games mechanics. Eberron gets around this both by addressing the issue head on, technically being appart of the D&D Multiverse even if closed off, and by having its stand in planes for spells to use, Eberron has a Shadowfell/Plane of Shadows, a Ethereal, its own Astral Plane, a Plane of Fey, ect... Theros and Ravnica were designed for MtG, not D&D, so they don't have these things.</blockquote>

Verification