Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Mistwell" data-source="post: 3206766" data-attributes="member: 2525">Name me one other immunity that ever stayed intact?&nbsp; This is a house rule magic item.&nbsp; The guy is asking for reasonable pricing for it.&nbsp; Overpricing it because you are upset about the greater issue of immunities not really being immunities isn't very fair to the OP.&nbsp; He deserves a fair estimate of the price along with the perceived problems, so his DM can make an informed decision.Gravestrike isn't all that powerful, even as a constant effect.&nbsp; The damage rogues do with sneak attack is around the damage done by a fighter type, and it has major flaws well beyond what the fighter has in doing that damage even with gravestrike (such as all of the methods that allow one to sneak attack have a clear-cut counter even in the core rules, and most high level NPCs have the counter readily available most of the time).&nbsp; Folks claiming it's an epic item just because it's powerful seem to be ignoring how powerful it is relative to the rest of the game.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Mistwell, post: 3206766, member: 2525"] Name me one other immunity that ever stayed intact? This is a house rule magic item. The guy is asking for reasonable pricing for it. Overpricing it because you are upset about the greater issue of immunities not really being immunities isn't very fair to the OP. He deserves a fair estimate of the price along with the perceived problems, so his DM can make an informed decision. Gravestrike isn't all that powerful, even as a constant effect. The damage rogues do with sneak attack is around the damage done by a fighter type, and it has major flaws well beyond what the fighter has in doing that damage even with gravestrike (such as all of the methods that allow one to sneak attack have a clear-cut counter even in the core rules, and most high level NPCs have the counter readily available most of the time). Folks claiming it's an epic item just because it's powerful seem to be ignoring how powerful it is relative to the rest of the game. [/QUOTE]

Verification