Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Neonchameleon" data-source="post: 9763569" data-attributes="member: 87792">The thing is Daggerheart is in no sense a heartbreaker. A heartbreaker needs to break the designer's heart. And Daggerheart is successful beyond wildest expectations as can be seen by the problems keeping it on shelves (I think the goal was measured in Candela Obscura).Here in the UK it's out of stock both in the Crit Role store and Amazon and Startplaying has it in third place behind 5e and PF2e. Despite one book, no first party adventures, and only having been out a few months.Calling Daggerheart a fantasy heartbreaker is like calling PF1e a fantasy heartbreaker. Which ... no. Neither break their designers hearts. And Daggerheart is waaaay further from D&D than most heartbreakers; the players don't even use d20s muchEdit: by your definition Shadowrun is a fantasy heartbreaker; elves, dragons, magic, and corporate offices as a dungeon-equivalent.</blockquote>