Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="stonegod" data-source="post: 5096751" data-attributes="member: 36973">The issues, I believe, isn't the sheet. I think the issue would be in the math checking (everything below the top part).This discussion has happened before in various forms. I'll restate my opinion (which is only that over here as I am not a L4W judge):- We need a summary section (as SC said). I prefer the LEB format to the L4W here.- We need some way of verifying math. Here, I think we should just require a player to provide one of (1) CB Summary, (2) The math templates, (3) Something else like the Google Spreadsheet that was started (but not finished)There are judges w/o access to the CB. Now, how many of them are highly active in review? I don't know. I know r1 does a lot of them and I'm pretty sure he does have it. I'm for making the barrier of entry lower.As for CB access for multi-folks: There is a reason the CB can be update five times per month (its almost enough for a gaming group of five/six).</blockquote>

[QUOTE="stonegod, post: 5096751, member: 36973"] The issues, I believe, isn't the sheet. I think the issue would be in the math checking (everything below the top part). This discussion has happened before in various forms. I'll restate my opinion (which is only that over here as I am not a L4W judge): - We need a summary section (as SC said). I prefer the LEB format to the L4W here. - We need some way of verifying math. Here, I think we should just require a player to provide one of (1) CB Summary, (2) The math templates, (3) Something else like the Google Spreadsheet that was started (but not finished) There are judges w/o access to the CB. Now, how many of them are highly active in review? I don't know. I know r1 does [b]a lot[/b] of them and I'm pretty sure he does have it. I'm for making the barrier of entry lower. As for CB access for multi-folks: There is a reason the CB can be update five times per month (its almost enough for a gaming group of five/six). [/QUOTE]

Verification