Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Maidhc O Casain" data-source="post: 5037735" data-attributes="member: 29558">As a player in the Moonwatch adventure, I have a 'horse in the race.' As KD has pointed out, this seems to be actually a roll play dispute rather than a rules dispute. True, Kalidrev is the one who made it a proposal - because it was pointed out that, while the discussion remained civil, it was going nowhere, really.While this could be made into a rules issue (actually has been, I guess, with the proposal), it shouldn't be; in my opinion, the rules are 'light' for a reason - to allow the GM to mold the adventure to the group, and to what he intends for the adventure.So my two cents in the pot is: leave this one up to the GM.[sblock=Aside]I'm not sure where this should go, but it seems somewhat pertinent to the discussion, so . . .KD, you are a great roll player, from what I've seen. And I agree 100% with your take on OOC vs. IC play. But I also believe that as a late addition to the group it's my responsibility to fit myself to the style of the group rather than trying to mold the group to my own preferences.I knew what I was getting into before I signed up - I had the entire history of the game available through the old posts. I knew going in that tactics were being discussed OOC, and that Telepathy was being used 'fast and loose.' So, I make the choice NOT to do so, and try my best to base my character's actions on what he knows.But it's not my place to come in and tell the rest of the group to change the way they've been playing - especially when the group has been cohesive and having a good time. And it's not my place to tell the GM to change the way he's been running the game - especially when the game has been going successfully and everyone's been having a good time.Again, I have tremendous respect for your roll play abilities and your knowledge of the rules, and for your integrity when it comes to playing your character. But even though it's in a different forum (OOC rather then IC) this seems like another attempt to get the GM and players in an established game (with a cohesive group where everyone was enjoying themselves), one that you had ample opportunity to examine prior to joining, to change the way they're playing.[/sblock]</blockquote>

Verification